title 'Oct Loyalist__debunker_ Guest_visitor List -' contains 100 files, 717 entries, 86 unique posts
Jun 4 2008, 10:20 AM
Post
#1
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Since there is already a Welcome and Newcomer forum for people who are legitimately looking for answers, it only seems fair to provide the same for our "debunking" and sometimes pointlessly argumentative friends. Please consider this an electronic "guest book" of sorts.
First of all, please read ALL OF the following IN ENTIRETY before making any posts in this Debate forum: Forum Rules http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?act=boardrules "Debunkers" Take Note http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=7462 To All Trolls & Shills: Please Read !, helpful advice for your first post http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=4993 When you get done with the above, why don't you take a little while to tell us about yourself? Some helpful information should/shall include: 1. What other userID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forums? 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) as told in the mainstream media (MSM), Kean-Hamilton 9/11 Commission, FEMA, and NIST reports on a scale of 0-100? 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Would these be "Gravysites" by any chance? 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? 7. Have we seen you under another userID here before? If so, which one(s)? ["Pinch," nicepants, Roark, Wibble, "foxy," etc.] 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones (animated GIF, appeal to ridicule, red herring, strawman, Ad Hominem, moving the goalpost, etc.)? 9. Do you prefer to get "scientific data and facts" from a tour guide and from anonymous online followers of a stage magician? 10. Are you under the employment and/or contracted under agencies of the United States Government? Thank you for taking the time to respond and please do enjoy your stay. [If you elect to not respond, you might get linked here anyway. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Note 1: Just to clarify the term loyalist: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/loyalist "one who is or remains loyal especially to a political cause, party, government, or sovereign" And a quick quiz- If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck it most likely is a __________? Note 2: You've got to work at it to get "invited" to this thread. If you have been referred here, it was in all likelihood by "invitation only" from a forum staff member. Please take a moment to seriously re-consider the thread where your "invitation" was posted, and what exactly your motivations are here at this forum... Note 3: FYI, "answering" our forum members' legitimate and sincere questions with yet more open-ended and un-answerable questions and/or rhetorical sophistry is NOT going to fly for very long here. PLEASE PROVIDE verifiable sources in your answers to the questions posed in this Debate forum. Also PLEASE keep quoted posts IN FULL CONTEXT in the Debate section (as in don't "quote mine," cross-quote different authors, and/or "cherry pick"- you will be called on that). *** Some apparently consider posting on this Debate forum to be a "right." It is NOT- it is a privelege that can and will be revoked for violation of any of the forum rules listed and/or linked to above IN THEIR ENTIRETY ***
Reason for edit: Draft 2.0
|
|
|
|
Jul 16 2008, 01:59 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Heeeeere's Roark!
May 21, 2008 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741344 [I think I taught him the word "plenum"] http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10743129 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10743130 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741490 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741508 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741486 NOTE: Contrary to Randiite claims, as of 13:53 EDT on July 16, 2008 Roark has never been banned here at P4911T [but the Randiites spell that Pfffft]. Roark has made 42 posts to date and does not indicate being in the "banned" users group- take a look at Roark's current profile. EDIT: From Roark's profile today: "Last Seen: 10th June 2008 - 03:44 PM " EDIT: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=13210
Reason for edit: Roark's absences
|
|
|
|
Jun 9 2008, 12:10 AM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Well, our first name/alias/sock in the book is the recent departure "nicepants."
For the curious, for the bored, and for the troll-ologists, one can find out more about nicepants' [mis?-]adventures here at: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=11938 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=11941 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=12546 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10742262 |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 04:07 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
QUOTE So what would you consider a good use of your time? Can you not see that debunking truthers sources and again again is a waste of OCTers time? A good use of time is moving forwards, not backwards. If you really think you are going to convince anyone here that we are wrong and everything that happened on 9/11 is as the government says, you indeed are wasting your time. QUOTE I came here looking for serious research but most, if not all I have seen as the same old stuff from Loose Change etc. Can the you at least offer the Forums theory for 9/11? CD, no planes? I think you're not looking hard enough. Pilots for 9/11 Truth.org is about the airplanes involved, and they have done a great amount of quality research based on official information and science. They work hard to be as accurate and factual as possible. If some of that research is transfered to LCF, great! Just remember that it originated here, not there. The Pilots do not offer theory, but it is discussed in the forum. If you check around, you will see that what is in the forum is not necessarily the view of the professional organization. The idea that the 'Forum' would have a theory is moot. The forum is a collection of individuals, each of whom has his/her own thoughts. Generally, we are not no-planers, if that is what you are asking. If you wish to know the individual thoughts and beliefs on that issue, I suggest that you read some of the current no-plane threads. We are a diverse crowd here. There is no 'like mind'. We are free individuals. Think about it. That's the bottom line of all of this. And you are free to believe whatever you wish. But understand, by and large the members of this forum do not believe the OCT nor will we ever. |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:23 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
I was told that this forum was the home of expert views and analysis. So I came here to read them and see if there is/was a conspiracy. I was hoping this forum would not be plagued by some of the childish moderation I have seen other forums. You know, the stuff where it is OK for truthers to personally attack "OCTers" but "OCTer" cant even respond to repeated attacks without getting banned and that sort of school playground stuff. So here I am...........
I am alone and for number 2 is 100 agree or disagree? The fact you are threatening to suspend me just for not answering a few questions really does this forum no credit. You are treating people who believe the Official Story as second rate humans. Do Truthers have a similar set of questions to answer? This all suggests you have something to hide and threats to suspend me is nothing short of censorship. The exact same thing you often accuse the US Government of. How Ironic. |
|
|
|
Dec 20 2008, 04:54 AM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Have you seen this anonymous internet troll recently?
http://www.fotosearch.com/bigcomp.asp?path...109/1094465.jpg |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:14 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
I did ask you to answer each question, which you did not. I would especially like for you to contemplate this one, and hopefully answer it.
"6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum?" Thanks. |
|
|
|
Jan 14 2009, 12:37 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Troll Posts: 39 Joined: 17-March 08 Member No.: 2,977 |
1. Boonedoggled here and LCF. Boone 870 at ATS and the GL site. Boone at Gaffney's site.
2. 99 3. No 4. Nickname. No. 5. No 6. Knowledge and information. 7. No 8. No 9. No preferences. 10. No |
|
|
|
Jun 4 2008, 11:04 AM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
|
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:48 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
QUOTE Parroting NIST and other OCT sources has been done over and over and over and is, quite fankly, a waste of our time and a diversion. So what would you consider a good use of your time? Can you not see that debunking truthers sources and again again is a waste of OCTers time? I came here looking for serious research but most, if not all I have seen as the same old stuff from Loose Change etc. Can the you at least offer the Forums theory for 9/11? CD, no planes? |
|
|
|
Jul 16 2008, 05:13 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Preface: I am not an "OCT Loyalist", so per the rules of this forum I am not obligated to even answer these questions, but I will since dmole was kind enough to answer some of them himself.
1. What other userID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forums? Adam_zapple, 909463. I don't participate in many forums, some newsgroups & irc. 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100? Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. No. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? Name/nickname combination. No. 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Would these be "Gravysites" by any chance? Wikipedia, Bazant's paper & response to jones' critique. 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? Hopefully get a few of my questions answered, and everyone learns something in the process. 7. Have we seen you under another userID here before? If so, which one(s)? [nicepants, Roark, Wibble, "foxy," etc.] No. 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones? No 9. Are you under the employment and/or contracted under agencies of the United States Government? No. *My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics. |
|
|
|
Dec 20 2008, 04:33 AM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
"When a troll become persistent and personal, you may need to consider the possibility that it has fermented into an Internet Stalker - equally pathetic, if not more so - but sometimes requiring weedkiller." [I advise spraying around the forum liberally, particularly your Pentagon, AA77, and Debate sections, but YMMV. ]
Case(s) in point: --------- "Dwight Shrute" Disinfo Agents http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15791 Rants By Dwight,, Troofer Extraordinaire/Imposter [nice title BTW, whoever came up with that more accurate one http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15793 the govt loyalist site Gls Demand Flight Path And Math http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15747 -------------- "Smrekar" G Force Questions, Split From 9/11: Attack On The Pentagon Now On Google http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15269 Smrekar's Dialog on Lightpoles and Momentum http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15195 Smrekar's Dialogue on Richard Gage AE911Truth, Split from WTC7 Oddity http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15180 Smrekar "housekeeping", part 2 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15188 |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 02:47 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
I was told to come here so I am Wibble, I only post as Wibble.
|
|
|
|
Jul 30 2008, 05:08 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 11 Joined: 8-November 07 Member No.: 2,458 |
"Debunkers" Take Note http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=7462 This link brings up a forum error for me. QUOTE When you get done with the above, why don't you take a little while to tell us about yourself? Some helpful information should/shall include: 1. What other userID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forums? 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) as told in the mainstream media (MSM), Kean-Hamilton 9/11 Commission, FEMA, and NIST reports on a scale of 0-100? 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Would these be "Gravysites" by any chance? 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? 7. Have we seen you under another userID here before? If so, which one(s)? [nicepants, Roark, Wibble, "foxy," etc.] 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones? 9. Do you prefer to get "scientific data and facts" from a tour guide and from anonymous online followers of a stage magician? 10. Are you under the employment and/or contracted under agencies of the United States Government? 1. I am Alex_V on 911forum.org.uk. 2. Generally I would say I support the official theory - I don't know how to put a figure on that. 80? I am a particular 'supporter' of NISTs report on the twin towers. 3. I'm on my own. 4. It's my name. 5. I think Mark Roberts site is full of interesting info, but my favourite site on the subject is 911myths.com - it seems to me a sober and informative assessment of some of the issues around the 9/11 conspiracy theories. 6. For reasons I'm not sure I quite understand, I am interested in 9/11 conspiracy theories - I hope to engage in stimulating discussion about them. 7. no 8. no 9. lol. I respect the opinions of a great many people, and it doesn't matter if they're magicians or tour guides. Or for that matter if they are experts in para-psychology, mormonism, UFOs or even self-proclaimed messiahs. 10. no |
|
|
|
Jun 4 2008, 10:23 AM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
pinned
|
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 10:02 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
QUOTE (Painter) I would like to pursue this answer a bit further with you, Adam. Rather than us putting forward a narrative, I'd prefer that you simply state your position. In your opinion, what actually happened on 9/11 and who was responsible for it? 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. This post has been edited by adam_zapple: Jul 18 2008, 10:10 AM |
|
|
|
Nov 10 2008, 09:53 AM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
jthomas failed to sign in at this thread but 62 of his? posts later:
Hi, Im jthomas, a skeptic, split from Welcome Forum + merged with another skeptical thread http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=11380 More jthomas Speculation that Aa77 Did Not Fly Over The Pentagon, Edited due to over-ambitious use of the word "proof" http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15355 EDIT: It looks like jthomas finally admitted to being "bje" at the illusionist site. I'm sure if he posts that same image a few dozen more times on a few more boards, no one will figure this out however... |
|
|
|
Jul 14 2008, 11:15 AM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
It looks like fransan missed a little and posted his? answers on a UA93 thread in the Aircraft section when referred to this thread earlier.
I'll help out and post those answers to the questions above here below now: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10745791 "About the questions: 1. What other user ID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forum Don´t have other user ID´s. Have a couple for credit cards, but I wouldn´t disclose those. I don´t visit forums on the web, except for this one. 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100? 100%. I believe it was a LIHOP event. 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. No. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? I like the sound of it, and has no significance or obscure reference. 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Yes. www.cs.purdue.edu They have an excellent simulation on the airliner crash and the damage it causes to one of the wtc towers. 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? I´m interested in reading what professionals in aviation are achieving in their research on 9/11. And the ideas and theories they have. Don´t expect to accomplish much since I don´t consider myself expert in any field discussed here. 7. Have we seen you under another user ID here before? If so, which one(s)? No. 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones? No." P.S. You can keep your credit cards private fransan, no one here asked you about those BTW. |
|
|
|
Jul 16 2008, 06:18 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Thank you Adam, post approved (unfortunately I already set the clock ticking after your 3rd refusal and I don't see an "undo" option here). You can attempt to post, but your moderation queue will run through tomorrow, I believe.
EDIT: Adam has also referred to a small portion of ONLY ONE of the Forum Rules above (taken out of context, of course). The full list is linked at the top of this thread for reference. 1st Staff request: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746804 2nd Staff request: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746816 3rd Staff request: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746824 3rd (or more) refusal: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746826
Reason for edit: Accounting
|
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 06:49 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
Just back checking the rules as requested etc.
QUOTE "one who is or remains loyal especially to a political cause, party, government, or sovereign" The truth is not a cause, party, government or sovereign. QUOTE And a quick quiz- If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck it most likely is a __________? Got it................Goose. Do I get a price. Or is this just more waffle old boy? |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:31 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
It is ironic, isn't it?
I don't think you understand. This is a serious reserch forum, not a debate club. Yes, we do reject the OCT because it is so full of holes there is almost no substance, more like a screen than swiss cheese. You can see right through it if you just look. This is based on years of research for most of us, and solid evidence. Parroting NIST and other OCT sources has been done over and over and over and is, quite fankly, a waste of our time and a diversion. Once again, if you have anything of substance, anything we don't already know, please offer it. |
|
|
|
Jul 17 2008, 02:39 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
. . . 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100? Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. . . . I would like to pursue this answer a bit further with you, Adam. Rather than us putting forward a narrative, I'd prefer that you simply state your position. In your opinion, what actually happened on 9/11 and who was responsible for it? |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 08:26 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Got it................Goose. Do I get a price. Or is this just more waffle old boy? Wibble, you seem obsessed with waffles. Are you hungry? Or Belgian perhaps? Since you haven't elaborated on your definition of "waffle" yet, or provided a sourced example of what you claim that I am "waffling" on, I did a search. Strangely, most of the hits came back linked to a Rupert Murdoch enterprise- is this where you get your "facts" then Wibble? http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,309196,00.html http://elections.foxnews.com/2008/04/22/po...win-pa-primary/ http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,303857,00.html http://bobmccarty.com/tag/fox-news/ Relevance of waffles (or pancakes or licorice for that matter) to 9/11 is? Oh yes, BTW: post #54 on the relevant topic at hand: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10744638 EDIT: Methinks someone might be "wibbling" again... EDIT2: As of 15:56 on July 16, 2008, Wibble isn't banned either (but still has a fairly high warning meter). From Wibble's profile today :"Last Seen: 15th June 2008 - 03:06 AM "
Reason for edit: Wibble's absences
|
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 04:15 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
I am alone and for number 2 is 100 agree or disagree? Read the questions and links above again Wibble. I recall #2 being about what percentage you support and/or believe the "Arab boxcutter" OCT. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/support 1: to endure bravely or quietly : bear 2 a (1): to promote the interests or cause of (2): to uphold or defend as valid or right : advocate <supports fair play> (3): to argue or vote for <supported the motion to lower taxes> b (1): assist, help <bombers supported the ground troops> (2): to act with (a star actor) (3): to bid in bridge so as to show support for c: to provide with substantiation : corroborate <support an alibi>3 a: to pay the costs of : maintain <support a family> b: to provide a basis for the existence or subsistence of <the island could probably support three A. B. C. Whipple> <support a habit> 4 a: to hold up or serve as a foundation or prop for b: to maintain (a price) at a desired level by purchases or loans; also : to maintain the price of by purchases or loans 5: to keep from fainting, yielding, or losing courage : comfort 6: to keep (something) going http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/believe 1 a: to have a firm religious faith b: to accept as true, genuine, or real <ideals we believe in> <believes in ghosts> 2: to have a firm conviction as to the goodness, efficacy, or ability of something <believe in exercise>3: to hold an opinion : think <I believe so> transitive verb 1 a: to consider to be true or honest <believe the reports> <you wouldn't believe how long it took> b: to accept the word or evidence of <I believe you> <couldn't believe my ears> 2: to hold as an opinion : suppose <I believe it will rain soon> For the record, you can believe whatever you want Wibble. I'll wager that you might find the J. Randi forum more to your liking- you are becoming tedious here. |
|
|
|
Jul 17 2008, 12:40 PM
Post
#3
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
EDIT: Adam has also referred to a small portion of ONLY ONE of the Forum Rules above (taken out of context, of course). I referred to the rule which you claimed required me to post the answers to the questions in this thread. I have not taken anything out of context, I posted the rule in question word-for-word. |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 11:38 AM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. I'm OK with the 1st line, except for the sourced evidence part... On the next two lines though- I'd prefer a specific "1" exactly what hit just so that we don't need to go through this questioning multiple times again in the near future (it's an efficiency "hang up" that I've got and will freely admit to). Then again, I owe Adam a bit more than the "duck" question at this point, so I'm willing to let this one go myself (Bad dMole!). |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:13 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
|
|
|
|
Jun 4 2008, 11:04 AM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
|
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 11:21 AM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. Well, that is about the skimpiest answer I could imagine and isn't at all satisfactory. To the question, "2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100?" you answered: Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. Sixty to eighty percent agreement is certainly more than fifty percent agreement but still leaves a 20 to 40 percent disagreement rate with the OTC. To me, even 20% is a high disagreement rate. But as you indicate this is relative to the narrative being discussed. So what I'm asking you is, what is the narrative with which you disagree twenty percent to forty percent? Moreover, you note with your asterisk, "*My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics." Fine, I have no problem with that. Using the standards of science, though, I don't understand how you can say what I've quoted above because the evidence doesn't support those claims and, worse, the official theory doesn't account for a lot of other evidence that has been accumulated. So, again, I ask the question. I'm asking for a narrative, here, not a list. EDIT -- just taking your list as presented above: 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? 1 hit the pentagon -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? 1 crashed in a rural area -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? Terrorists were responsible. -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? |
|
|
|
Jun 20 2008, 09:52 AM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() Group: Respected Member Posts: 802 Joined: 20-October 06 Member No.: 117 |
You are treating people who believe the Official Story as second rate humans. That's a little harsh, although you could argue that it is those who supported the OCT all along who are both directly and indirectly responsible for the financial mess we find ourselves in today. I mean, for aguments sake, let's assume the OCT were 100% accurate... can you not deny that at the very least you brought this on yourselves? Like Lorraine Bobbit, the Arabs took enough abuse and decided to hit back! While such actions are deplorable, can you honestly blame them? If I were you I'd draw a line under the whole thing and get on with your life! |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 12:33 PM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Well, that is about the skimpiest answer I could imagine and isn't at all satisfactory. To the question, "2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100?" you answered: Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. Sixty to eighty percent agreement is certainly more than fifty percent agreement but still leaves a 20 to 40 percent disagreement rate with the OTC. To me, even 20% is a high disagreement rate. But as you indicate this is relative to the narrative being discussed. So what I'm asking you is, what is the narrative with which you disagree twenty percent to forty percent? There are many different narratives...I chose the figure because I did not know which particular narrative you were referring to. You call it the "boxcutter Arab", but I can't recall which particular narrative includes statements about boxcutters. Again, if you point me to a specific narrative, I'll give you a specific percentage. Moreover, you note with your asterisk, "*My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics." Fine, I have no problem with that. Using the standards of science, though, I don't understand how you can say what I've quoted above because the evidence doesn't support those claims and, worse, the official theory doesn't account for a lot of other evidence that has been accumulated. Which specific evidence doesn't support those claims? No one theory is going to be able to account for every piece of evidence, expecting that is unrealistic. So, again, I ask the question. I'm asking for a narrative, here, not a list. Narrative: Hijackers took control of 4 planes. They may or may not have had weapons (some reported that the hijackers claimed to have bombs). Since previous hijackings of commercial aircraft in the US usually resulted in a safe landing, no one (on the first 3 flights) would have thought any differently. The policy of the airlines was to cooperate with the hijackers, which they did. Some or all of the air crews were either incapacitated or killed at which point the hijackers took over the controls of the aircraft and flew them into their targets, except for flight 93 which crashed in a field, presumably due to intervention by their passengers who knew that they would be killed if they did not react. The 2 wtc towers, after suffering the impacts of the jets and fires sparked by their large fuel load, both collapsed, damaging nearby structures including WTC7 which also collapsed. 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it (Many, including myself, on live television) 1 hit the pentagon -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it. (AA77) 1 crashed in a rural area -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it. (United 93) Terrorists were responsible. -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People who saw the terrorists reported it. Same question to you, Painter. Your narrative, please. |
|
|
|
Jun 9 2008, 12:10 AM
Post
#4
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Well, our first name/alias/sock in the book is the recent departure "nicepants."
For the curious, for the bored, and for the troll-ologists, one can find out more about nicepants' [mis?-]adventures here at: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=11938 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=11941 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=12546 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10742262 |
|
|
|
Jul 17 2008, 02:08 PM
Post
#4
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
I referred to the rule which you claimed required me to post the answers to the questions in this thread. I have not taken anything out of context, I posted the rule in question word-for-word. Tsk tsk Adam- there's more than ONE rule... Go take another look (or see my reply above for that matter). Also you're getting a little "words in my mouth" here aren't you Adam? I didn't reference ONLY ONE rule anywhere did I? I think you'll find that Oceans Flow, the post above, and I have been talking about ALL the Debate Forum Rules (3 links, 10 questions now- thanks Adam, but your 9 answers are sufficient in this case). FWIW You did miss that quiz about ducks too... FYI Adam: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wishful_thinking "Wishful thinking is the formation of beliefs and making decisions according to what might be pleasing to imagine instead of by appealing to evidence or rationality." |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 02:46 PM
Post
#5
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
There are many different narratives...I chose the figure because I did not know which particular narrative you were referring to. You call it the "boxcutter Arab", but I can't recall which particular narrative includes statements about boxcutters. Again, if you point me to a specific narrative, I'll give you a specific percentage. FYI Adam: http://www.rcfp.org/moussaoui/jpg/size600/FO08301-1.jpg ![]() Please try to be specific (re: percentage and so forth). |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 02:17 PM
Post
#5
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
. . . -People saw it. . . . Given your stated allegiance to scientific principles, do you consider "people saw it" to be all that is necessary to establish fact? As for my narrative, I don't have one exactly. What I have are a lot of pieces to a puzzle that doesn't make sense, so far as generating a comprehensive alternative narrative but, equally, belie the official narrative we're repeatedly given. I don't find that surprising, however, as my predisposition is that the events of 9/11 are an on-going, state sponsored, psychological operation -- a black-op, psy-op, social-driving mind-f*ck with a large counter-intelligence aspect that is meant to send people like myself chasing red geese in pursuit of wild herrings while the perps play croquet with pink flamingoes in a fun-house of mirrors so compartmentalized that even they don't know exactly who and how or what and why. Obfuscation is the name of the game. NO ONE is supposed to know what is really going on beyond their 'need to know' compartment.
Ron Suskind quoting an unnamed White House source (most likely Karl Rove) in a 10.17.04 New York Times Sunday Magazine article. What I know is the first and most important step in covering-up a murder is get rid of the murder weapon. To date, not ONE piece of airline wreckage has been positively identified by serialized part # by the NTSB as belonging to the alleged hijacked plane at its respective crash site. OR, if such has been positively identified by the NTSB, such identification is being withheld from the public despite repeated FOIA requests. This extraordinary fact is not reported by the corporate owned media. But, then, there are many extraordinary facts about 9/11 that aren't covered by said media -- such as the fact that the data retrieved from the alleged FDR of Flight 77, in many significant details, does not correspond with or corroborate the physical damage path found in the Pentagon and its environs; such as the fact that eyewitnesses, some of them Pentagon employees, emphatically state on record that the plane they saw and believe hit the building was traveling on a trajectory that makes it impossible for it to have caused said damage. There are many other things I could name that are established facts in regards to 9/11 that are not covered by the same said media and even much of the 'alternative' media as well. All of which reinforces my above predisposition that what we are dealing with here is a matter of national security of such extreme importance to those in power that their underlings aren't even allowed to discuss whether or not certain pieces of information are classified beyond their access level. From all of this I deduce that what we are dealing with here are high crimes, treason, mass murder and a conspiracy of such consequence that the fate not only of our nation but very likely the world depends upon our responses to it. Whether or not President Bush, for example, was privy to all the details of this operation from the outset of his installation in the Office by the Supreme Court is impossible for me to say. I can only say that his "reaction" to the news from his Secretary, not to mention that of his Secret Service entourage, upon being informed of the second WTC hit, that, specifically, "America is under attack," and that from that moment a state of emergency was in effect, putting into play COG (continuity of government) contingencies, is beyond counter intuitive. He just f*cking sat there on camera in a room full of remedial readers for a space of approximately 10 minutes while other allegedly high-jacked aircraft remained aloft, one of them in route toward what one would assume to be the most heavily monitored and defended air-space on earth. I could go on and on and on with this but the point has been made. It isn't necessary to construct a compelling alternative narrative to de-construct a false narrative. As with scientific theories, all that is necessary is to show that the theory (in this case a narrative) does NOT account for all the factual evidence observed. We have that in spades. Whatever the truth may be, it isn't what we've been told -- and the consequences, should they ever be fully embraced, are historically unprecedented. |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 02:47 PM
Post
#5
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
I was told to come here so I am Wibble, I only post as Wibble.
|
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:06 PM
Post
#6
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
|
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:04 PM
Post
#6
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Given your stated allegiance to scientific principles, do you consider "people saw it" to be all that is necessary to establish fact? No, but it is a pretty devastating piece of evidence to anyone who thinks that none of these planes actually crashed. To clarify: When I say "people saw it", I'm not just referring to the actual impact, but the plane debris, victims, plane parts, etc witnessed by rescue workers, etc. What I know is the first and most important step in covering-up a murder is get rid of the murder weapon. To date, not ONE piece of airline wreckage has been positively identified by serialized part # by the NTSB as belonging to the alleged hijacked plane at its respective crash site. OR, if such has been positively identified by the NTSB, such identification is being withheld from the public despite repeated FOIA requests. We know which planes went missing, and they just so happen to match the descriptions of the planes people saw crashing. Interestingly enough, the passengers aboard each of the planes are also missing (though some of their remains were DNA-identified) and the planes in question haven't been seen since. What additional gain would there be in cataloging the serial numbers of each part in the wreckage? (or is this just excuse to claim that the evidence provided is insufficient?) I snipped the rest of your post which contained various anomalies & interesting tidbits, none of which prove the existence of any such conspiracy. Does it bother you at all that you are not able to form any of these facts into a single cohesive narrative of what you believe actually took place? I would bet that if you could do so, there would be more anomalies in your own narrative than you've discovered in the "official story". (Would that then mean that your theory is wrong?) |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:13 PM
Post
#6
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
|
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:08 PM
Post
#7
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
|
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:14 PM
Post
#7
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
I did ask you to answer each question, which you did not. I would especially like for you to contemplate this one, and hopefully answer it.
"6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum?" Thanks. |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:23 PM
Post
#8
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
I was told that this forum was the home of expert views and analysis. So I came here to read them and see if there is/was a conspiracy. I was hoping this forum would not be plagued by some of the childish moderation I have seen other forums. You know, the stuff where it is OK for truthers to personally attack "OCTers" but "OCTer" cant even respond to repeated attacks without getting banned and that sort of school playground stuff. So here I am...........
I am alone and for number 2 is 100 agree or disagree? The fact you are threatening to suspend me just for not answering a few questions really does this forum no credit. You are treating people who believe the Official Story as second rate humans. Do Truthers have a similar set of questions to answer? This all suggests you have something to hide and threats to suspend me is nothing short of censorship. The exact same thing you often accuse the US Government of. How Ironic. |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:31 PM
Post
#9
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
It is ironic, isn't it?
I don't think you understand. This is a serious reserch forum, not a debate club. Yes, we do reject the OCT because it is so full of holes there is almost no substance, more like a screen than swiss cheese. You can see right through it if you just look. This is based on years of research for most of us, and solid evidence. Parroting NIST and other OCT sources has been done over and over and over and is, quite fankly, a waste of our time and a diversion. Once again, if you have anything of substance, anything we don't already know, please offer it. |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 03:48 PM
Post
#10
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
QUOTE Parroting NIST and other OCT sources has been done over and over and over and is, quite fankly, a waste of our time and a diversion. So what would you consider a good use of your time? Can you not see that debunking truthers sources and again again is a waste of OCTers time? I came here looking for serious research but most, if not all I have seen as the same old stuff from Loose Change etc. Can the you at least offer the Forums theory for 9/11? CD, no planes? |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 04:07 PM
Post
#11
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
QUOTE So what would you consider a good use of your time? Can you not see that debunking truthers sources and again again is a waste of OCTers time? A good use of time is moving forwards, not backwards. If you really think you are going to convince anyone here that we are wrong and everything that happened on 9/11 is as the government says, you indeed are wasting your time. QUOTE I came here looking for serious research but most, if not all I have seen as the same old stuff from Loose Change etc. Can the you at least offer the Forums theory for 9/11? CD, no planes? I think you're not looking hard enough. Pilots for 9/11 Truth.org is about the airplanes involved, and they have done a great amount of quality research based on official information and science. They work hard to be as accurate and factual as possible. If some of that research is transfered to LCF, great! Just remember that it originated here, not there. The Pilots do not offer theory, but it is discussed in the forum. If you check around, you will see that what is in the forum is not necessarily the view of the professional organization. The idea that the 'Forum' would have a theory is moot. The forum is a collection of individuals, each of whom has his/her own thoughts. Generally, we are not no-planers, if that is what you are asking. If you wish to know the individual thoughts and beliefs on that issue, I suggest that you read some of the current no-plane threads. We are a diverse crowd here. There is no 'like mind'. We are free individuals. Think about it. That's the bottom line of all of this. And you are free to believe whatever you wish. But understand, by and large the members of this forum do not believe the OCT nor will we ever. |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 04:15 PM
Post
#12
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
I am alone and for number 2 is 100 agree or disagree? Read the questions and links above again Wibble. I recall #2 being about what percentage you support and/or believe the "Arab boxcutter" OCT. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/support 1: to endure bravely or quietly : bear 2 a (1): to promote the interests or cause of (2): to uphold or defend as valid or right : advocate <supports fair play> (3): to argue or vote for <supported the motion to lower taxes> b (1): assist, help <bombers supported the ground troops> (2): to act with (a star actor) (3): to bid in bridge so as to show support for c: to provide with substantiation : corroborate <support an alibi>3 a: to pay the costs of : maintain <support a family> b: to provide a basis for the existence or subsistence of <the island could probably support three A. B. C. Whipple> <support a habit> 4 a: to hold up or serve as a foundation or prop for b: to maintain (a price) at a desired level by purchases or loans; also : to maintain the price of by purchases or loans 5: to keep from fainting, yielding, or losing courage : comfort 6: to keep (something) going http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/believe 1 a: to have a firm religious faith b: to accept as true, genuine, or real <ideals we believe in> <believes in ghosts> 2: to have a firm conviction as to the goodness, efficacy, or ability of something <believe in exercise>3: to hold an opinion : think <I believe so> transitive verb 1 a: to consider to be true or honest <believe the reports> <you wouldn't believe how long it took> b: to accept the word or evidence of <I believe you> <couldn't believe my ears> 2: to hold as an opinion : suppose <I believe it will rain soon> For the record, you can believe whatever you want Wibble. I'll wager that you might find the J. Randi forum more to your liking- you are becoming tedious here. |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 06:49 PM
Post
#13
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 69 Joined: 3-May 08 Member No.: 3,271 |
Just back checking the rules as requested etc.
QUOTE "one who is or remains loyal especially to a political cause, party, government, or sovereign" The truth is not a cause, party, government or sovereign. QUOTE And a quick quiz- If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck it most likely is a __________? Got it................Goose. Do I get a price. Or is this just more waffle old boy? |
|
|
|
Jun 14 2008, 08:26 PM
Post
#14
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Got it................Goose. Do I get a price. Or is this just more waffle old boy? Wibble, you seem obsessed with waffles. Are you hungry? Or Belgian perhaps? Since you haven't elaborated on your definition of "waffle" yet, or provided a sourced example of what you claim that I am "waffling" on, I did a search. Strangely, most of the hits came back linked to a Rupert Murdoch enterprise- is this where you get your "facts" then Wibble? http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,309196,00.html http://elections.foxnews.com/2008/04/22/po...win-pa-primary/ http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,303857,00.html http://bobmccarty.com/tag/fox-news/ Relevance of waffles (or pancakes or licorice for that matter) to 9/11 is? Oh yes, BTW: post #54 on the relevant topic at hand: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10744638 EDIT: Methinks someone might be "wibbling" again... EDIT2: As of 15:56 on July 16, 2008, Wibble isn't banned either (but still has a fairly high warning meter). From Wibble's profile today :"Last Seen: 15th June 2008 - 03:06 AM "
Reason for edit: Wibble's absences
|
|
|
|
Jun 20 2008, 09:52 AM
Post
#15
|
|
![]() Group: Respected Member Posts: 802 Joined: 20-October 06 Member No.: 117 |
You are treating people who believe the Official Story as second rate humans. That's a little harsh, although you could argue that it is those who supported the OCT all along who are both directly and indirectly responsible for the financial mess we find ourselves in today. I mean, for aguments sake, let's assume the OCT were 100% accurate... can you not deny that at the very least you brought this on yourselves? Like Lorraine Bobbit, the Arabs took enough abuse and decided to hit back! While such actions are deplorable, can you honestly blame them? If I were you I'd draw a line under the whole thing and get on with your life! |
|
|
|
Jul 14 2008, 11:15 AM
Post
#16
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
It looks like fransan missed a little and posted his? answers on a UA93 thread in the Aircraft section when referred to this thread earlier.
I'll help out and post those answers to the questions above here below now: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10745791 "About the questions: 1. What other user ID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forum Don´t have other user ID´s. Have a couple for credit cards, but I wouldn´t disclose those. I don´t visit forums on the web, except for this one. 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100? 100%. I believe it was a LIHOP event. 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. No. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? I like the sound of it, and has no significance or obscure reference. 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Yes. www.cs.purdue.edu They have an excellent simulation on the airliner crash and the damage it causes to one of the wtc towers. 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? I´m interested in reading what professionals in aviation are achieving in their research on 9/11. And the ideas and theories they have. Don´t expect to accomplish much since I don´t consider myself expert in any field discussed here. 7. Have we seen you under another user ID here before? If so, which one(s)? No. 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones? No." P.S. You can keep your credit cards private fransan, no one here asked you about those BTW. |
|
|
|
Jul 16 2008, 01:59 PM
Post
#17
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Heeeeere's Roark!
May 21, 2008 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741344 [I think I taught him the word "plenum"] http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10743129 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10743130 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741490 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741508 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10741486 NOTE: Contrary to Randiite claims, as of 13:53 EDT on July 16, 2008 Roark has never been banned here at P4911T [but the Randiites spell that Pfffft]. Roark has made 42 posts to date and does not indicate being in the "banned" users group- take a look at Roark's current profile. EDIT: From Roark's profile today: "Last Seen: 10th June 2008 - 03:44 PM " EDIT: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=13210
Reason for edit: Roark's absences
|
|
|
|
Jul 16 2008, 05:13 PM
Post
#18
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Preface: I am not an "OCT Loyalist", so per the rules of this forum I am not obligated to even answer these questions, but I will since dmole was kind enough to answer some of them himself.
1. What other userID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forums? Adam_zapple, 909463. I don't participate in many forums, some newsgroups & irc. 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100? Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. No. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? Name/nickname combination. No. 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Would these be "Gravysites" by any chance? Wikipedia, Bazant's paper & response to jones' critique. 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? Hopefully get a few of my questions answered, and everyone learns something in the process. 7. Have we seen you under another userID here before? If so, which one(s)? [nicepants, Roark, Wibble, "foxy," etc.] No. 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones? No 9. Are you under the employment and/or contracted under agencies of the United States Government? No. *My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics. |
|
|
|
Jul 16 2008, 06:18 PM
Post
#19
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Thank you Adam, post approved (unfortunately I already set the clock ticking after your 3rd refusal and I don't see an "undo" option here). You can attempt to post, but your moderation queue will run through tomorrow, I believe.
EDIT: Adam has also referred to a small portion of ONLY ONE of the Forum Rules above (taken out of context, of course). The full list is linked at the top of this thread for reference. 1st Staff request: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746804 2nd Staff request: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746816 3rd Staff request: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746824 3rd (or more) refusal: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10746826
Reason for edit: Accounting
|
|
|
|
Jul 17 2008, 12:40 PM
Post
#20
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
EDIT: Adam has also referred to a small portion of ONLY ONE of the Forum Rules above (taken out of context, of course). I referred to the rule which you claimed required me to post the answers to the questions in this thread. I have not taken anything out of context, I posted the rule in question word-for-word. |
|
|
|
Jul 17 2008, 02:08 PM
Post
#21
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
I referred to the rule which you claimed required me to post the answers to the questions in this thread. I have not taken anything out of context, I posted the rule in question word-for-word. Tsk tsk Adam- there's more than ONE rule... Go take another look (or see my reply above for that matter). Also you're getting a little "words in my mouth" here aren't you Adam? I didn't reference ONLY ONE rule anywhere did I? I think you'll find that Oceans Flow, the post above, and I have been talking about ALL the Debate Forum Rules (3 links, 10 questions now- thanks Adam, but your 9 answers are sufficient in this case). FWIW You did miss that quiz about ducks too... FYI Adam: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wishful_thinking "Wishful thinking is the formation of beliefs and making decisions according to what might be pleasing to imagine instead of by appealing to evidence or rationality." |
|
|
|
Jun 4 2008, 10:20 AM
Post
#21
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Since there is already a Welcome and Newcomer forum for people who are legitimately looking for answers, it only seems fair to provide the same for our "debunking" and sometimes pointlessly argumentative friends. Please consider this an electronic "guest book" of sorts.
First of all, please read ALL OF the following IN ENTIRETY before making any posts in this Debate forum: Forum Rules http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?act=boardrules "Debunkers" Take Note http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=7462 To All Trolls & Shills: Please Read !, helpful advice for your first post http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=4993 When you get done with the above, why don't you take a little while to tell us about yourself? Some helpful information should/shall include: 1. What other userID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forums? 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) as told in the mainstream media (MSM), Kean-Hamilton 9/11 Commission, FEMA, and NIST reports on a scale of 0-100? 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Would these be "Gravysites" by any chance? 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? 7. Have we seen you under another userID here before? If so, which one(s)? ["Pinch," nicepants, Roark, Wibble, "foxy," etc.] 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones (animated GIF, appeal to ridicule, red herring, strawman, Ad Hominem, moving the goalpost, etc.)? 9. Do you prefer to get "scientific data and facts" from a tour guide and from anonymous online followers of a stage magician? 10. Are you under the employment and/or contracted under agencies of the United States Government? Thank you for taking the time to respond and please do enjoy your stay. [If you elect to not respond, you might get linked here anyway. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Note 1: Just to clarify the term loyalist: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/loyalist "one who is or remains loyal especially to a political cause, party, government, or sovereign" And a quick quiz- If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck it most likely is a __________? Note 2: You've got to work at it to get "invited" to this thread. If you have been referred here, it was in all likelihood by "invitation only" from a forum staff member. Please take a moment to seriously re-consider the thread where your "invitation" was posted, and what exactly your motivations are here at this forum... Note 3: FYI, "answering" our forum members' legitimate and sincere questions with yet more open-ended and un-answerable questions and/or rhetorical sophistry is NOT going to fly for very long here. PLEASE PROVIDE verifiable sources in your answers to the questions posed in this Debate forum. Also PLEASE keep quoted posts IN FULL CONTEXT in the Debate section (as in don't "quote mine," cross-quote different authors, and/or "cherry pick"- you will be called on that). *** Some apparently consider posting on this Debate forum to be a "right." It is NOT- it is a privelege that can and will be revoked for violation of any of the forum rules listed and/or linked to above IN THEIR ENTIRETY ***
Reason for edit: Draft 2.0
|
|
|
|
Nov 10 2008, 09:53 AM
Post
#22
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
jthomas failed to sign in at this thread but 62 of his? posts later:
Hi, Im jthomas, a skeptic, split from Welcome Forum + merged with another skeptical thread http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=11380 More jthomas Speculation that Aa77 Did Not Fly Over The Pentagon, Edited due to over-ambitious use of the word "proof" http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15355 EDIT: It looks like jthomas finally admitted to being "bje" at the illusionist site. I'm sure if he posts that same image a few dozen more times on a few more boards, no one will figure this out however... |
|
|
|
Jan 14 2009, 12:37 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Troll Posts: 39 Joined: 17-March 08 Member No.: 2,977 |
1. Boonedoggled here and LCF. Boone 870 at ATS and the GL site. Boone at Gaffney's site.
2. 99 3. No 4. Nickname. No. 5. No 6. Knowledge and information. 7. No 8. No 9. No preferences. 10. No |
|
|
|
Jul 30 2008, 05:08 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 11 Joined: 8-November 07 Member No.: 2,458 |
"Debunkers" Take Note http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=7462 This link brings up a forum error for me. QUOTE When you get done with the above, why don't you take a little while to tell us about yourself? Some helpful information should/shall include: 1. What other userID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forums? 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) as told in the mainstream media (MSM), Kean-Hamilton 9/11 Commission, FEMA, and NIST reports on a scale of 0-100? 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Would these be "Gravysites" by any chance? 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? 7. Have we seen you under another userID here before? If so, which one(s)? [nicepants, Roark, Wibble, "foxy," etc.] 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones? 9. Do you prefer to get "scientific data and facts" from a tour guide and from anonymous online followers of a stage magician? 10. Are you under the employment and/or contracted under agencies of the United States Government? 1. I am Alex_V on 911forum.org.uk. 2. Generally I would say I support the official theory - I don't know how to put a figure on that. 80? I am a particular 'supporter' of NISTs report on the twin towers. 3. I'm on my own. 4. It's my name. 5. I think Mark Roberts site is full of interesting info, but my favourite site on the subject is 911myths.com - it seems to me a sober and informative assessment of some of the issues around the 9/11 conspiracy theories. 6. For reasons I'm not sure I quite understand, I am interested in 9/11 conspiracy theories - I hope to engage in stimulating discussion about them. 7. no 8. no 9. lol. I respect the opinions of a great many people, and it doesn't matter if they're magicians or tour guides. Or for that matter if they are experts in para-psychology, mormonism, UFOs or even self-proclaimed messiahs. 10. no |
|
|
|
Jul 17 2008, 02:10 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Tsk tsk Adam- there's more than ONE rule... Go take another look (or see my reply above for that matter). Did I ever claim that there was only one rule? You accused me of taking that rule "out of context", but I posted it word-for-word. If the meaning of that rule is different than it's word-for-word explanation, please advise. |
|
|
|
Dec 20 2008, 04:54 AM
Post
#22
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Have you seen this anonymous internet troll recently?
http://www.fotosearch.com/bigcomp.asp?path...109/1094465.jpg |
|
|
|
Dec 20 2008, 04:33 AM
Post
#22
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
"When a troll become persistent and personal, you may need to consider the possibility that it has fermented into an Internet Stalker - equally pathetic, if not more so - but sometimes requiring weedkiller." [I advise spraying around the forum liberally, particularly your Pentagon, AA77, and Debate sections, but YMMV. ]
Case(s) in point: --------- "Dwight Shrute" Disinfo Agents http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15791 Rants By Dwight,, Troofer Extraordinaire/Imposter [nice title BTW, whoever came up with that more accurate one http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15793 the govt loyalist site Gls Demand Flight Path And Math http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15747 -------------- "Smrekar" G Force Questions, Split From 9/11: Attack On The Pentagon Now On Google http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15269 Smrekar's Dialog on Lightpoles and Momentum http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15195 Smrekar's Dialogue on Richard Gage AE911Truth, Split from WTC7 Oddity http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15180 Smrekar "housekeeping", part 2 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15188 |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 10:02 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
QUOTE (Painter) I would like to pursue this answer a bit further with you, Adam. Rather than us putting forward a narrative, I'd prefer that you simply state your position. In your opinion, what actually happened on 9/11 and who was responsible for it? 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. This post has been edited by adam_zapple: Jul 18 2008, 10:10 AM |
|
|
|
Jul 17 2008, 02:39 PM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
. . . 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100? Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. . . . I would like to pursue this answer a bit further with you, Adam. Rather than us putting forward a narrative, I'd prefer that you simply state your position. In your opinion, what actually happened on 9/11 and who was responsible for it? |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 11:38 AM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. I'm OK with the 1st line, except for the sourced evidence part... On the next two lines though- I'd prefer a specific "1" exactly what hit just so that we don't need to go through this questioning multiple times again in the near future (it's an efficiency "hang up" that I've got and will freely admit to). Then again, I owe Adam a bit more than the "duck" question at this point, so I'm willing to let this one go myself (Bad dMole!). |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 11:21 AM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. Well, that is about the skimpiest answer I could imagine and isn't at all satisfactory. To the question, "2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100?" you answered: Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. Sixty to eighty percent agreement is certainly more than fifty percent agreement but still leaves a 20 to 40 percent disagreement rate with the OTC. To me, even 20% is a high disagreement rate. But as you indicate this is relative to the narrative being discussed. So what I'm asking you is, what is the narrative with which you disagree twenty percent to forty percent? Moreover, you note with your asterisk, "*My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics." Fine, I have no problem with that. Using the standards of science, though, I don't understand how you can say what I've quoted above because the evidence doesn't support those claims and, worse, the official theory doesn't account for a lot of other evidence that has been accumulated. So, again, I ask the question. I'm asking for a narrative, here, not a list. EDIT -- just taking your list as presented above: 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? 1 hit the pentagon -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? 1 crashed in a rural area -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? Terrorists were responsible. -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 12:33 PM
Post
#24
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Well, that is about the skimpiest answer I could imagine and isn't at all satisfactory. To the question, "2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100?" you answered: Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. Sixty to eighty percent agreement is certainly more than fifty percent agreement but still leaves a 20 to 40 percent disagreement rate with the OTC. To me, even 20% is a high disagreement rate. But as you indicate this is relative to the narrative being discussed. So what I'm asking you is, what is the narrative with which you disagree twenty percent to forty percent? There are many different narratives...I chose the figure because I did not know which particular narrative you were referring to. You call it the "boxcutter Arab", but I can't recall which particular narrative includes statements about boxcutters. Again, if you point me to a specific narrative, I'll give you a specific percentage. Moreover, you note with your asterisk, "*My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics." Fine, I have no problem with that. Using the standards of science, though, I don't understand how you can say what I've quoted above because the evidence doesn't support those claims and, worse, the official theory doesn't account for a lot of other evidence that has been accumulated. Which specific evidence doesn't support those claims? No one theory is going to be able to account for every piece of evidence, expecting that is unrealistic. So, again, I ask the question. I'm asking for a narrative, here, not a list. Narrative: Hijackers took control of 4 planes. They may or may not have had weapons (some reported that the hijackers claimed to have bombs). Since previous hijackings of commercial aircraft in the US usually resulted in a safe landing, no one (on the first 3 flights) would have thought any differently. The policy of the airlines was to cooperate with the hijackers, which they did. Some or all of the air crews were either incapacitated or killed at which point the hijackers took over the controls of the aircraft and flew them into their targets, except for flight 93 which crashed in a field, presumably due to intervention by their passengers who knew that they would be killed if they did not react. The 2 wtc towers, after suffering the impacts of the jets and fires sparked by their large fuel load, both collapsed, damaging nearby structures including WTC7 which also collapsed. 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it (Many, including myself, on live television) 1 hit the pentagon -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it. (AA77) 1 crashed in a rural area -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it. (United 93) Terrorists were responsible. -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People who saw the terrorists reported it. Same question to you, Painter. Your narrative, please. |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 10:02 AM
Post
#24
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
QUOTE (Painter) I would like to pursue this answer a bit further with you, Adam. Rather than us putting forward a narrative, I'd prefer that you simply state your position. In your opinion, what actually happened on 9/11 and who was responsible for it? 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. This post has been edited by adam_zapple: Jul 18 2008, 10:10 AM |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 02:46 PM
Post
#25
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
There are many different narratives...I chose the figure because I did not know which particular narrative you were referring to. You call it the "boxcutter Arab", but I can't recall which particular narrative includes statements about boxcutters. Again, if you point me to a specific narrative, I'll give you a specific percentage. FYI Adam: http://www.rcfp.org/moussaoui/jpg/size600/FO08301-1.jpg ![]() Please try to be specific (re: percentage and so forth). |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 02:17 PM
Post
#25
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
. . . -People saw it. . . . Given your stated allegiance to scientific principles, do you consider "people saw it" to be all that is necessary to establish fact? As for my narrative, I don't have one exactly. What I have are a lot of pieces to a puzzle that doesn't make sense, so far as generating a comprehensive alternative narrative but, equally, belie the official narrative we're repeatedly given. I don't find that surprising, however, as my predisposition is that the events of 9/11 are an on-going, state sponsored, psychological operation -- a black-op, psy-op, social-driving mind-f*ck with a large counter-intelligence aspect that is meant to send people like myself chasing red geese in pursuit of wild herrings while the perps play croquet with pink flamingoes in a fun-house of mirrors so compartmentalized that even they don't know exactly who and how or what and why. Obfuscation is the name of the game. NO ONE is supposed to know what is really going on beyond their 'need to know' compartment.
Ron Suskind quoting an unnamed White House source (most likely Karl Rove) in a 10.17.04 New York Times Sunday Magazine article. What I know is the first and most important step in covering-up a murder is get rid of the murder weapon. To date, not ONE piece of airline wreckage has been positively identified by serialized part # by the NTSB as belonging to the alleged hijacked plane at its respective crash site. OR, if such has been positively identified by the NTSB, such identification is being withheld from the public despite repeated FOIA requests. This extraordinary fact is not reported by the corporate owned media. But, then, there are many extraordinary facts about 9/11 that aren't covered by said media -- such as the fact that the data retrieved from the alleged FDR of Flight 77, in many significant details, does not correspond with or corroborate the physical damage path found in the Pentagon and its environs; such as the fact that eyewitnesses, some of them Pentagon employees, emphatically state on record that the plane they saw and believe hit the building was traveling on a trajectory that makes it impossible for it to have caused said damage. There are many other things I could name that are established facts in regards to 9/11 that are not covered by the same said media and even much of the 'alternative' media as well. All of which reinforces my above predisposition that what we are dealing with here is a matter of national security of such extreme importance to those in power that their underlings aren't even allowed to discuss whether or not certain pieces of information are classified beyond their access level. From all of this I deduce that what we are dealing with here are high crimes, treason, mass murder and a conspiracy of such consequence that the fate not only of our nation but very likely the world depends upon our responses to it. Whether or not President Bush, for example, was privy to all the details of this operation from the outset of his installation in the Office by the Supreme Court is impossible for me to say. I can only say that his "reaction" to the news from his Secretary, not to mention that of his Secret Service entourage, upon being informed of the second WTC hit, that, specifically, "America is under attack," and that from that moment a state of emergency was in effect, putting into play COG (continuity of government) contingencies, is beyond counter intuitive. He just f*cking sat there on camera in a room full of remedial readers for a space of approximately 10 minutes while other allegedly high-jacked aircraft remained aloft, one of them in route toward what one would assume to be the most heavily monitored and defended air-space on earth. I could go on and on and on with this but the point has been made. It isn't necessary to construct a compelling alternative narrative to de-construct a false narrative. As with scientific theories, all that is necessary is to show that the theory (in this case a narrative) does NOT account for all the factual evidence observed. We have that in spades. Whatever the truth may be, it isn't what we've been told -- and the consequences, should they ever be fully embraced, are historically unprecedented. |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 11:21 AM
Post
#25
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. Well, that is about the skimpiest answer I could imagine and isn't at all satisfactory. To the question, "2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100?" you answered: Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. Sixty to eighty percent agreement is certainly more than fifty percent agreement but still leaves a 20 to 40 percent disagreement rate with the OTC. To me, even 20% is a high disagreement rate. But as you indicate this is relative to the narrative being discussed. So what I'm asking you is, what is the narrative with which you disagree twenty percent to forty percent? Moreover, you note with your asterisk, "*My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics." Fine, I have no problem with that. Using the standards of science, though, I don't understand how you can say what I've quoted above because the evidence doesn't support those claims and, worse, the official theory doesn't account for a lot of other evidence that has been accumulated. So, again, I ask the question. I'm asking for a narrative, here, not a list. EDIT -- just taking your list as presented above: 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? 1 hit the pentagon -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? 1 crashed in a rural area -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? Terrorists were responsible. -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 11:38 AM
Post
#26
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers 1 hit the pentagon 1 crashed in a rural area Terrorists were responsible. Same question to you, Painter. I'm OK with the 1st line, except for the sourced evidence part... On the next two lines though- I'd prefer a specific "1" exactly what hit just so that we don't need to go through this questioning multiple times again in the near future (it's an efficiency "hang up" that I've got and will freely admit to). Then again, I owe Adam a bit more than the "duck" question at this point, so I'm willing to let this one go myself (Bad dMole!). |
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:06 PM
Post
#26
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
|
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:04 PM
Post
#26
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Given your stated allegiance to scientific principles, do you consider "people saw it" to be all that is necessary to establish fact? No, but it is a pretty devastating piece of evidence to anyone who thinks that none of these planes actually crashed. To clarify: When I say "people saw it", I'm not just referring to the actual impact, but the plane debris, victims, plane parts, etc witnessed by rescue workers, etc. What I know is the first and most important step in covering-up a murder is get rid of the murder weapon. To date, not ONE piece of airline wreckage has been positively identified by serialized part # by the NTSB as belonging to the alleged hijacked plane at its respective crash site. OR, if such has been positively identified by the NTSB, such identification is being withheld from the public despite repeated FOIA requests. We know which planes went missing, and they just so happen to match the descriptions of the planes people saw crashing. Interestingly enough, the passengers aboard each of the planes are also missing (though some of their remains were DNA-identified) and the planes in question haven't been seen since. What additional gain would there be in cataloging the serial numbers of each part in the wreckage? (or is this just excuse to claim that the evidence provided is insufficient?) I snipped the rest of your post which contained various anomalies & interesting tidbits, none of which prove the existence of any such conspiracy. Does it bother you at all that you are not able to form any of these facts into a single cohesive narrative of what you believe actually took place? I would bet that if you could do so, there would be more anomalies in your own narrative than you've discovered in the "official story". (Would that then mean that your theory is wrong?) |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 12:33 PM
Post
#27
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Well, that is about the skimpiest answer I could imagine and isn't at all satisfactory. To the question, "2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) on a scale of 0-100?" you answered: Probably 60-80%*, but I would have to know the exact narrative you're referring to. Sixty to eighty percent agreement is certainly more than fifty percent agreement but still leaves a 20 to 40 percent disagreement rate with the OTC. To me, even 20% is a high disagreement rate. But as you indicate this is relative to the narrative being discussed. So what I'm asking you is, what is the narrative with which you disagree twenty percent to forty percent? There are many different narratives...I chose the figure because I did not know which particular narrative you were referring to. You call it the "boxcutter Arab", but I can't recall which particular narrative includes statements about boxcutters. Again, if you point me to a specific narrative, I'll give you a specific percentage. Moreover, you note with your asterisk, "*My loyalties are to the laws of science and physics. It doesn't matter to me which side the government is on, I will side with science and physics." Fine, I have no problem with that. Using the standards of science, though, I don't understand how you can say what I've quoted above because the evidence doesn't support those claims and, worse, the official theory doesn't account for a lot of other evidence that has been accumulated. Which specific evidence doesn't support those claims? No one theory is going to be able to account for every piece of evidence, expecting that is unrealistic. So, again, I ask the question. I'm asking for a narrative, here, not a list. Narrative: Hijackers took control of 4 planes. They may or may not have had weapons (some reported that the hijackers claimed to have bombs). Since previous hijackings of commercial aircraft in the US usually resulted in a safe landing, no one (on the first 3 flights) would have thought any differently. The policy of the airlines was to cooperate with the hijackers, which they did. Some or all of the air crews were either incapacitated or killed at which point the hijackers took over the controls of the aircraft and flew them into their targets, except for flight 93 which crashed in a field, presumably due to intervention by their passengers who knew that they would be killed if they did not react. The 2 wtc towers, after suffering the impacts of the jets and fires sparked by their large fuel load, both collapsed, damaging nearby structures including WTC7 which also collapsed. 2 Commercial Airliners hit the WTC towers -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it (Many, including myself, on live television) 1 hit the pentagon -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it. (AA77) 1 crashed in a rural area -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People saw it. (United 93) Terrorists were responsible. -- What evidence do you have to verify that claim? -People who saw the terrorists reported it. Same question to you, Painter. Your narrative, please. |
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:08 PM
Post
#27
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
|
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 02:17 PM
Post
#28
|
|
![]() ∞* M E R C U R I A L *∞ Group: Respected Member Posts: 5,871 Joined: 25-August 06 From: SFO Member No.: 16 |
. . . -People saw it. . . . Given your stated allegiance to scientific principles, do you consider "people saw it" to be all that is necessary to establish fact? As for my narrative, I don't have one exactly. What I have are a lot of pieces to a puzzle that doesn't make sense, so far as generating a comprehensive alternative narrative but, equally, belie the official narrative we're repeatedly given. I don't find that surprising, however, as my predisposition is that the events of 9/11 are an on-going, state sponsored, psychological operation -- a black-op, psy-op, social-driving mind-f*ck with a large counter-intelligence aspect that is meant to send people like myself chasing red geese in pursuit of wild herrings while the perps play croquet with pink flamingoes in a fun-house of mirrors so compartmentalized that even they don't know exactly who and how or what and why. Obfuscation is the name of the game. NO ONE is supposed to know what is really going on beyond their 'need to know' compartment.
Ron Suskind quoting an unnamed White House source (most likely Karl Rove) in a 10.17.04 New York Times Sunday Magazine article. What I know is the first and most important step in covering-up a murder is get rid of the murder weapon. To date, not ONE piece of airline wreckage has been positively identified by serialized part # by the NTSB as belonging to the alleged hijacked plane at its respective crash site. OR, if such has been positively identified by the NTSB, such identification is being withheld from the public despite repeated FOIA requests. This extraordinary fact is not reported by the corporate owned media. But, then, there are many extraordinary facts about 9/11 that aren't covered by said media -- such as the fact that the data retrieved from the alleged FDR of Flight 77, in many significant details, does not correspond with or corroborate the physical damage path found in the Pentagon and its environs; such as the fact that eyewitnesses, some of them Pentagon employees, emphatically state on record that the plane they saw and believe hit the building was traveling on a trajectory that makes it impossible for it to have caused said damage. There are many other things I could name that are established facts in regards to 9/11 that are not covered by the same said media and even much of the 'alternative' media as well. All of which reinforces my above predisposition that what we are dealing with here is a matter of national security of such extreme importance to those in power that their underlings aren't even allowed to discuss whether or not certain pieces of information are classified beyond their access level. From all of this I deduce that what we are dealing with here are high crimes, treason, mass murder and a conspiracy of such consequence that the fate not only of our nation but very likely the world depends upon our responses to it. Whether or not President Bush, for example, was privy to all the details of this operation from the outset of his installation in the Office by the Supreme Court is impossible for me to say. I can only say that his "reaction" to the news from his Secretary, not to mention that of his Secret Service entourage, upon being informed of the second WTC hit, that, specifically, "America is under attack," and that from that moment a state of emergency was in effect, putting into play COG (continuity of government) contingencies, is beyond counter intuitive. He just f*cking sat there on camera in a room full of remedial readers for a space of approximately 10 minutes while other allegedly high-jacked aircraft remained aloft, one of them in route toward what one would assume to be the most heavily monitored and defended air-space on earth. I could go on and on and on with this but the point has been made. It isn't necessary to construct a compelling alternative narrative to de-construct a false narrative. As with scientific theories, all that is necessary is to show that the theory (in this case a narrative) does NOT account for all the factual evidence observed. We have that in spades. Whatever the truth may be, it isn't what we've been told -- and the consequences, should they ever be fully embraced, are historically unprecedented. |
|
|
|
Jul 18 2008, 02:46 PM
Post
#29
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
There are many different narratives...I chose the figure because I did not know which particular narrative you were referring to. You call it the "boxcutter Arab", but I can't recall which particular narrative includes statements about boxcutters. Again, if you point me to a specific narrative, I'll give you a specific percentage. FYI Adam: http://www.rcfp.org/moussaoui/jpg/size600/FO08301-1.jpg ![]() Please try to be specific (re: percentage and so forth). |
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:04 PM
Post
#30
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
Given your stated allegiance to scientific principles, do you consider "people saw it" to be all that is necessary to establish fact? No, but it is a pretty devastating piece of evidence to anyone who thinks that none of these planes actually crashed. To clarify: When I say "people saw it", I'm not just referring to the actual impact, but the plane debris, victims, plane parts, etc witnessed by rescue workers, etc. What I know is the first and most important step in covering-up a murder is get rid of the murder weapon. To date, not ONE piece of airline wreckage has been positively identified by serialized part # by the NTSB as belonging to the alleged hijacked plane at its respective crash site. OR, if such has been positively identified by the NTSB, such identification is being withheld from the public despite repeated FOIA requests. We know which planes went missing, and they just so happen to match the descriptions of the planes people saw crashing. Interestingly enough, the passengers aboard each of the planes are also missing (though some of their remains were DNA-identified) and the planes in question haven't been seen since. What additional gain would there be in cataloging the serial numbers of each part in the wreckage? (or is this just excuse to claim that the evidence provided is insufficient?) I snipped the rest of your post which contained various anomalies & interesting tidbits, none of which prove the existence of any such conspiracy. Does it bother you at all that you are not able to form any of these facts into a single cohesive narrative of what you believe actually took place? I would bet that if you could do so, there would be more anomalies in your own narrative than you've discovered in the "official story". (Would that then mean that your theory is wrong?) |
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:06 PM
Post
#31
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 43 Joined: 11-July 08 Member No.: 3,696 |
|
|
|
|
Jul 21 2008, 04:08 PM
Post
#32
|
|
![]() aka Oceans Flow Group: Respected Member Posts: 3,211 Joined: 19-October 06 From: Oregon Member No.: 108 |
|
|
|
|
Jul 30 2008, 05:08 PM
Post
#33
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 11 Joined: 8-November 07 Member No.: 2,458 |
"Debunkers" Take Note http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=7462 This link brings up a forum error for me. QUOTE When you get done with the above, why don't you take a little while to tell us about yourself? Some helpful information should/shall include: 1. What other userID's do you frequently use online? At what websites or forums? 2. What percentage(s) would you estimate that you support and/or believe the "Official" "boxcutter Arab" Conspiracy Theory (OT, OCT, or OGCT) as told in the mainstream media (MSM), Kean-Hamilton 9/11 Commission, FEMA, and NIST reports on a scale of 0-100? 3. Did you bring any of your associates with you? If so, how many are in your party? Please have them each sign this guest book too. 4. Why did you choose your particular userID? Does it have any significance or obscure reference that you would like to share with us? 5. Do you have any online websites or resources that you would like to recommend to us? Would these be "Gravysites" by any chance? 6. MOST IMPORTANTLY: What exactly do you hope to accomplish at or bring to this Forum? 7. Have we seen you under another userID here before? If so, which one(s)? [nicepants, Roark, Wibble, "foxy," etc.] 8. Do you have any favorite rhetorical techniques? Which ones? 9. Do you prefer to get "scientific data and facts" from a tour guide and from anonymous online followers of a stage magician? 10. Are you under the employment and/or contracted under agencies of the United States Government? 1. I am Alex_V on 911forum.org.uk. 2. Generally I would say I support the official theory - I don't know how to put a figure on that. 80? I am a particular 'supporter' of NISTs report on the twin towers. 3. I'm on my own. 4. It's my name. 5. I think Mark Roberts site is full of interesting info, but my favourite site on the subject is 911myths.com - it seems to me a sober and informative assessment of some of the issues around the 9/11 conspiracy theories. 6. For reasons I'm not sure I quite understand, I am interested in 9/11 conspiracy theories - I hope to engage in stimulating discussion about them. 7. no 8. no 9. lol. I respect the opinions of a great many people, and it doesn't matter if they're magicians or tour guides. Or for that matter if they are experts in para-psychology, mormonism, UFOs or even self-proclaimed messiahs. 10. no |
|
|
|
Nov 10 2008, 09:53 AM
Post
#34
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
jthomas failed to sign in at this thread but 62 of his? posts later:
Hi, Im jthomas, a skeptic, split from Welcome Forum + merged with another skeptical thread http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=11380 More jthomas Speculation that Aa77 Did Not Fly Over The Pentagon, Edited due to over-ambitious use of the word "proof" http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15355 EDIT: It looks like jthomas finally admitted to being "bje" at the illusionist site. I'm sure if he posts that same image a few dozen more times on a few more boards, no one will figure this out however... |
|
|
|
Dec 20 2008, 04:33 AM
Post
#35
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
"When a troll become persistent and personal, you may need to consider the possibility that it has fermented into an Internet Stalker - equally pathetic, if not more so - but sometimes requiring weedkiller." [I advise spraying around the forum liberally, particularly your Pentagon, AA77, and Debate sections, but YMMV. ]
Case(s) in point: --------- "Dwight Shrute" Disinfo Agents http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15791 Rants By Dwight,, Troofer Extraordinaire/Imposter [nice title BTW, whoever came up with that more accurate one http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15793 the govt loyalist site Gls Demand Flight Path And Math http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15747 -------------- "Smrekar" G Force Questions, Split From 9/11: Attack On The Pentagon Now On Google http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15269 Smrekar's Dialog on Lightpoles and Momentum http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15195 Smrekar's Dialogue on Richard Gage AE911Truth, Split from WTC7 Oddity http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15180 Smrekar "housekeeping", part 2 http://pf911t.org/forum//index....showtopic=15188 |
|
|
|
Dec 20 2008, 04:54 AM
Post
#36
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Have you seen this anonymous internet troll recently?
http://www.fotosearch.com/bigcomp.asp?path...109/1094465.jpg |
|
|
|
Jan 14 2009, 12:37 PM
Post
#37
|
|
|
Group: Troll Posts: 39 Joined: 17-March 08 Member No.: 2,977 |
1. Boonedoggled here and LCF. Boone 870 at ATS and the GL site. Boone at Gaffney's site.
2. 99 3. No 4. Nickname. No. 5. No 6. Knowledge and information. 7. No 8. No 9. No preferences. 10. No |
|
|
|
![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 11:08 AM |
![]() ![]() |
![]() ![]() |
![]() ![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 14th November 2020 - 05:21 PM |
Oct Loyalist/"debunker" Guest/visitor List, Sign in here please |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 11:09 AM |
![]() ![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 14th November 2020 - 05:19 PM |
![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 14th November 2020 - 05:20 PM |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 08:29 AM |
![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 09:17 AM |
dMole Oct Loyalist/"debunker" Guest/visitor List Jun 4 2008, 10:20 AM
rob balsamo pinned Jun 4 2008, 10:23 AM
painter QUOTE (dMole @ Jun 4 2008, 07:20 AM) Than... Jun 4 2008, 11:04 AM
dMole Well, our first name/alias/sock in the book is the... Jun 9 2008, 12:10 AM
Wibble I was told to come here so I am Wibble, I only pos... Jun 14 2008, 02:47 PM
painter QUOTE (Wibble @ Jun 14 2008, 11:47 AM) I ... Jun 14 2008, 03:13 PM
Oceans Flow I did ask you to answer each question, which you d... Jun 14 2008, 03:14 PM
Wibble I was told that this forum was the home of expert ... Jun 14 2008, 03:23 PM
dMole QUOTE (Wibble @ Jun 14 2008, 01:23 PM) I ... Jun 14 2008, 04:15 PM
Beached QUOTE (Wibble @ Jun 14 2008, 08:23 PM) Yo... Jun 20 2008, 09:52 AM
Oceans Flow It is ironic, isn't it?
I don't think you... Jun 14 2008, 03:31 PM
Wibble QUOTE Parroting NIST and other OCT sources has bee... Jun 14 2008, 03:48 PM
Oceans Flow QUOTE So what would you consider a good use of you... Jun 14 2008, 04:07 PM
Wibble Just back checking the rules as requested etc.
... Jun 14 2008, 06:49 PM
dMole QUOTE (Wibble @ Jun 14 2008, 04:49 PM) Go... Jun 14 2008, 08:26 PM
dMole It looks like fransan missed a little and posted h... Jul 14 2008, 11:15 AM
dMole Heeeeere's Roark!
May 21, 2008
http://pil... Jul 16 2008, 01:59 PM
adam_zapple Preface: I am not an "OCT Loyalist", so... Jul 16 2008, 05:13 PM
painter QUOTE (adam_zapple @ Jul 16 2008, 02:13 P... Jul 17 2008, 02:39 PM
dMole Thank you Adam, post approved (unfortunately I alr... Jul 16 2008, 06:18 PM
adam_zapple QUOTE (dMole @ Jul 16 2008, 06:18 PM) EDI... Jul 17 2008, 12:40 PM
dMole QUOTE (adam_zapple @ Jul 17 2008, 10:40 A... Jul 17 2008, 02:08 PM
adam_zapple QUOTE (Painter)I would like to pursue this answer ... Jul 18 2008, 10:02 AM
painter QUOTE (adam_zapple @ Jul 18 2008, 07:02 A... Jul 18 2008, 11:21 AM

adam_zapple QUOTE (painter @ Jul 18 2008, 11:21 AM) W... Jul 18 2008, 12:33 PM

painter QUOTE (adam_zapple @ Jul 18 2008, 09:33 A... Jul 18 2008, 02:17 PM


adam_zapple QUOTE (painter @ Jul 18 2008, 02:17 PM) G... Jul 21 2008, 04:04 PM

dMole QUOTE (adam_zapple @ Jul 18 2008, 10:33 A... Jul 18 2008, 02:46 PM

adam_zapple QUOTE (dMole @ Jul 18 2008, 02:46 PM) Ple... Jul 21 2008, 04:06 PM

Oceans Flow QUOTE (adam_zapple @ Jul 18 2008, 12:06 P... Jul 21 2008, 04:08 PM
dMole QUOTE (adam_zapple @ Jul 18 2008, 08:02 A... Jul 18 2008, 11:38 AM
Alex_V QUOTE (dMole @ Jun 2 2008, 01:20 PM) ... Jul 30 2008, 05:08 PM
dMole jthomas failed to sign in at this thread but 62 of... Nov 10 2008, 09:53 AM
dMole "When a troll become persistent and personal,... Dec 20 2008, 04:33 AM
dMole Have you seen this anonymous internet troll recent... Dec 20 2008, 04:54 AM
Boonedoggled 1. Boonedoggled here and LCF. Boone 870 at ATS an... Jan 14 2009, 12:37 PMSource file links: