title 'Speed Ground Ual175 -' contains 237 files, 1728 entries, 172 unique posts
Apr 3 2014, 05:47 AM
Post
#1
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Bonjour.
Y a t'il quelqu'un pour parler en français et me traduire. C'est pour exposer mes travaux sur l'étude des données radar de Newark. Je trouve qu'elles peuvent être plus basses que cela a été écrit par le NTSB. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 08:19 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Sinon, le NTSB aurait repris des données du même style et les aurait communiquées telles quelles.
Otherwise, the NTSB would have taken data of the same style and would have communicated as is. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:39 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
That's what scares me!
Why do not they trust a single radar? With excel I recalculated the latitudes and longitudes of the studs EWR and I did not detect significant difference. |
|
|
|
Apr 4 2014, 12:57 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
You can adjust the curve by putting values in the "adjust" column Mine are in red in the next column, you can copy them. |
|
|
|
Apr 20 2014, 04:55 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Has anyone tried my Excel file?
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 06:20 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Good morning.
Is there someone to speak French and translate for me. This is to expose my work on the study of radar data Newark. I think they may be lower than it was written by the NTSB. I have to go through translate.google.fr and it is very long for me. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 09:04 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 4 2014, 01:24 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 05:33 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:02 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Now you do what you want. Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 07:55 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I would like to have the opinion who the next person is a member of your association:
Hammish Brannan Former United Kingdom air defense ground enviroment (UKADGE) RADAR technician Primary and secondary ground radar systems ATC & airborne systems (including radio) as an instructor for the Ministry of Defence (MOD) |
|
|
|
Apr 6 2014, 12:13 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Could someone tell me if he tried my excel table and what he thinks?
I want to know this smooth curve is envisagable as compulsorily older credible, realistic approach and that we must consider. |
|
|
|
Apr 19 2014, 05:36 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Some tell me that I must take into account several radars to get a more accurate curve.
This is impossible with the uncertainty of the timestamp between two different radars. In addition, provide additional points on a curve, then they will also be scattered will only increase the possibilities to draw a curve. It is better to make a curve of each radar and compare the results. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 12:51 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Ok ! What time begins for you, the final portion of flight ?
This post has been edited by tournesol01: May 7 2014, 12:54 PM |
|
|
|
Apr 27 2014, 01:40 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Sorry for my english, but this is a translation in line with translate.google.fr
|
|
|
|
May 2 2014, 08:33 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:19 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 41 Joined: 29-March 08 Member No.: 3,061 |
thankyou rob and tournesol01 for your interesting discussion!
I am sorry I can't contribute anything useful because I am lacking knowledge in this field. But I just wonder why in the pdf-file linked above (http://unique.annonce.free.fr/downloads/Plot_transpondeur_UAL175_CDR.pdf) are 2 pages (p 2,3) "transmission verification report", where the first shows the date "09/06/2001" ... But also, as an IT professional I am curious to learn why "magnetic recordings of internal computer processing" could in any way NOT represent an accurate representation of the data received, processed and stored during computer processing? The second sentence in this paragraph (p 5) I think relates to "the document" you look at, not the data ... |
|
|
|
Apr 4 2014, 07:23 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Respected Member Posts: 1,111 Joined: 7-November 07 From: Prague or France Member No.: 2,452 |
I'm also quite not sure about the end of the curve. The impact speed - as multiple radar analyses and also multiple video analyses (see here, here, here and here) show was quite definitely higher than 470 kts.
If you want to discus this in French, you can contact me via PM - I would think it will be better to keep this forum here in international aviation language - the English. Si tu veux discuter ca en français, tu peux me contacter par PM - Je pense que ca sera mieux tenir cet forum ici en la lague de l'aviation internationale - L'anglais |
|
|
|
May 1 2014, 03:15 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Si quelqu'un parmis vous pouvait me dire le type, la marque et la précision en azimut du radar de Newark en 2001, je pourrais continuer ma démarche......
J'ai mis, pour obtenir ce graphe une précision de +/-0,3° et la courbe donnée par le NTSB tombe en dessous dans les dernières secondes. Pourquoi ? If anyone among you could tell me the type, brand and azimuth accuracy of radar Newark in 2001, I could continue my approach ...... I put, for this graph an accuracy of + / -0.3 ° and the curve given by the NTSB falls below in the final seconds. Why? Visiblement, c'est une hérésie de ce servir d'un radar pour établir la vitesse d'un avion ! Obviously, this is a heresy that used radar to determine the speed of an airplane ! ![]() ![]() Vous pouvez dans ce fichier entrer la valeur de précision de votre choix. Merci de bien vouloir critiquer mon travail et de me donner les corrections à appliquer si vous trouvez des mauvais calculs. You can in this file enter the value of precision of your choice. Thank you kindly to critique my work and give me the corrections to be applied if you find any miscalculations. Fichier Excel |
|
|
|
May 3 2014, 12:58 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Active Forum Pilot Posts: 477 Joined: 16-August 07 From: Upstate NY/VT border Member No.: 1,719 |
May we please see the UA175 speed data source?
|
|
|
|
Apr 26 2014, 02:30 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I can still show you that I do not do just about anything with the data NTSB:
This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 26 2014, 02:32 PM |
|
|
|
Apr 25 2014, 09:24 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Speed is too high, then it is not a usual plane that hit the WTC Rather than: A boeing hit the WTC but the speed given by the NTSB may be overstated It is still easier and convincing to believe miscalculations than seeking shenanigans with aircraft doctored, right? This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 25 2014, 09:25 AM |
|
|
|
Apr 22 2014, 08:54 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
For simplicity, an electromagnetic wave emitted from an antenna consisting of a simple vertical mast , as the wave propagates created by dropping a pebble in water.
We observe concentric waves that move away from the place where the stone was " splash " For a radar antenna , one should consider, at time t , a sector oriented , more or less wide , previous concentric circles. Radar sprinkles its electromagnetic wave while a sector simultaneously. If a boat replaces here the plane , when the wave will reach , its location is random in the sector . However , the azimuth radar is necessarily that given by the determined angle between the geographic North and the angle bisector of the sector oriented when the wave reaches the boat . The boat can be at the right or left of the bisector , we have here a correction to find the actual azimuth of the boat. Bringing to a more realistic azimuth angle changes the distance between the radar blips . It is found that with a speed increased so that one side and down the other . This is what I want to convey in my Excel file.
This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 22 2014, 08:56 AM |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 06:42 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Here is what I propose as speed curve:
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:36 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Si c'est à cause d'un radar trop éloigné que la vitesse n'a pas été calculée jusqu'au bout, c'est bien que la précision doit faire défaut, non ?
If this is due to a radar too far as speed was not calculated until the end, it is that the accuracy is lacking, right? |
|
|
|
Apr 22 2014, 11:44 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I would like to discuss with him my theory ! This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 22 2014, 11:47 AM |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:16 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
The speed curve NTSB is not the same as I got with excel. Have you also tried to reconstruct these curves?
|
|
|
|
Apr 28 2014, 10:08 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
By what means the NTSB as smoothed the curve?
The blue curve is the curve without retouching
|
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 03:45 PM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Un contrôleur aérien doit maintenir les avions, dont il a la charge, espacés d'au moins trois miles nautiques. Cet espace est très supérieur à un écart dû à la précision du radar.
Qu'il n'y est pas d'incident est donc normal. An air traffic controller must maintain the aircraft, which he is responsible, spaced at least three nautical miles. This space is greater than a difference caused by the precision of the radar. That there is no incident is normal. Les vitesses qui sont calculées, oui ! En théorie, mais je sais qu'un avion ne vole plus en dessous de sa vitesse de décrochage. Speeds that are calculated , yes! In theory, but I know a plane stops flying below its stall speed. NON ! Les vitesses affichées sur les écrans radar sont celles envoyées par le transpondeur ! Il n'y a pas, dans ce cas, de calculs à effectuer. Je ne sais pas si une vitesse s'affiche si le transpondeur est en mode 3/A. A vous de me le dire !! NO ! The speeds displayed on the radar screens are those sent by the transponder ! There is not , in this case , to perform calculations . I do not know if speed is displayed if the transponder is in mode 3 / A. You tell me ! |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 11:35 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I will begin to explain my point of view:
On the bottom graph are red dots. These are the values of ground speeds calculated from the raw radar data Newark (EWR) Vertical dispersion of these points is elevated when they should be follow up with more regularity, not zigzagging. A plane takes time to change gear. Where does this dispersion? On the one error of less than 1 degree on the azimuth of the radar blips. Playing on the value of the azimuth replace the radar blips in a better configuration and allows to obtain a curve closer to reality speed (the blue dots) Speeds are reduced. Altitude and Range remain the same. The downward slope of the altitude of ual175 flight is nearly constant. Finally, the pilot pushed the engine a short time before impact. Then he may have slowed for the aircraft is not disintegrated before impact. This is my own belief, what do you think of that ? This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 3 2014, 11:37 AM |
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 04:45 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
![]() La précision requise pour un calcul de vitesse est insuffisante. Au mieux avec un écart max de +/- .7° par rapport à l'axe du lobe principal, la marge d'erreur est de 140 kts! Et encore, il faut pour cela être à moins de 10 miles nautique du radar. ASR-9 et ARSR-4 ont la même imprécision. The precision required for a calculation speed is low. At best with a maximum deviation of + / - .7 ° relative to the axis of the main lobe, the margin of error is 140 kts! And again, this requires to be less than 10 nautical miles from the radar. ASR-9 and ARSR-4 have the same vagueness. |
|
|
|
Apr 17 2014, 07:00 AM
Post
#2
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I added more blocks to my Excel file.
For now here are their geographic positions:
|
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 04:48 AM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
The precision required for a calculation speed is low. At best with a maximum deviation of + / - .7 ° relative to the axis of the main lobe, the margin of error is 140 kts! With such a large margin for error... (according to you) how can thousands of aircraft possibly arrive and depart the NYC terminal Area safely each day with speed assignments referenced from ASR radar in real time? QUOTE the margin of error is 140 kts! Just so we have this clear. You are saying that the speeds reported could be in error as much as 650 kts... and as low as 370 kts? And that those who are assigned speeds using ASR radar.... for example.. ATC assigns 200 knots upon arrival into JFK..... but really NY TRACON would be seeing as much as 340 knots or as low as 60 knots on their ASR screens? Really? |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:44 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
That's what scares me! Why do not they trust a single radar? The NY Terminal area is a very busy place serving 6-7 very busy airports in close proximity. Speeds are being assigned to aircraft daily, in real time, so they don't run into each other. I certainly feel very comfortable having more than one radar looking at my airplane when getting vectored for an approach into LGA, JFK, EWR, TEB, HPN... or transitioning to FRG or MMU. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:19 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
The speed curve NTSB is not the same as I got with excel. Have you also tried to reconstruct these curves? No, I calculated the speeds using Lat/long positions of the RADES data. The results are similar to the raw EWR data you have plotted above. However, the end of your curve is not accurate and does not reflect the raw data you have plotted. Again, keep in mind, the NTSB used more than just EWR radar for the speed study. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 06:42 AM
Post
#3
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Here is what I propose as speed curve:
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:01 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
I will begin to explain my point of view: On the bottom graph are red dots. These are the values of ground speeds calculated from the raw radar data Newark (EWR) Those look pretty accurate. I calculated similar results with the RADES data.... it shows the aircraft exceeding 500 knots with values as high as 540 for roughly the last 3 minutes of flight. The NTSB is correct with regard to the speeds reported. Keep in mind, they also used radar from JFK, LGA, and HPN... and also did a Video Speed study with similar results. |
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 04:23 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
NO ! The speeds displayed on the radar screens are those sent by the transponder ! Really? Can you please tell me what type of transponder sends speed information? QUOTE I do not know if speed is displayed if the transponder is in mode 3 / A. You tell me ! Speed is displayed to ATC based on distance/time calculations made by the Radar hardware itself in real time and is constantly updating. The transponder does not send speed information. Read and learn... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_tran...de_A_and_Mode_C "UA175" was squawking Mode C throughout its entire flight... although the squawk code was changed... (according to the official story). Your speed margins for error are absurd. If such margins existed, planes would be running into each other daily at every major hub across the globe. Again, the speeds reported by the NTSB have been cross-checked using several different radar facilities and video analysis. The speeds reported by the NTSB are accurate. The speeds reported (both yours and the NTSB) exceed the performance of a standard 767 by a wide margin. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:06 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
May 5 2014, 08:11 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
A boeing hit the WTC but the speed given by the NTSB may be overstated The speeds you have calculated, reaching 540 knots... and closing at nearly 500 knots. (in which you admit you may have made errors), are still too excessive for a standard Boeing 767 based on precedent.... ![]() With that said, when cross-checking the various radar data, the NTSB, and their video speed study, the NTSB calculations are accurate. |
|
|
|
Apr 4 2014, 03:08 PM
Post
#3
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
You can adjust the curve by putting values in the "adjust" column Mine are in red in the next column, you can copy them. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:33 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
thankyou rob and tournesol01 for your interesting discussion! I am sorry I can't contribute anything useful because I am lacking knowledge in this field. lol... that doesn't stop tournesol from giving his two cents... he still thinks a transponder can transmit speed data after I have already given him a source which shows it does not, in any mode... QUOTE But I just wonder why in the pdf-file linked above (http://unique.annonce.free.fr/downloads/Plot_transpondeur_UAL175_CDR.pdf) are 2 pages (p 2,3) "transmission verification report", where the first shows the date "09/06/2001" ... Yes, that is interesting.... I noticed that too. The two pages are from different fax machines.. .so the first inaccurate date could be explained by an incorrect date setting on that particular machine. QUOTE But also, as an IT professional I am curious to learn why "magnetic recordings of internal computer processing" could in any way NOT represent an accurate representation of the data received, processed and stored during computer processing? The second sentence in this paragraph (p 5) I think relates to "the document" you look at, not the data ... I think they were referencing the graphic itself since it shows some offsets. If the date/time on page 3 is accurate (09/11/2001 1607... im assuming in Zulu), the fax was sent only hours after the events.. so clearly the data was a preliminary rough output. |
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 05:41 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
"This document is derived from computer magnetic recordings of internal computer processing. It is not an exact representation of the control position display." - page 5 of your pdf Emphasis mine... The data in your document also terminates more than 3 mins prior to "impact". Again, transponders do not send speed information. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 11:48 AM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
JFK, EWR, HPN, SWF and RADES radar were all used in determining aircraft performance (speed) during the final portion of flight (not just 'impact'). The details and files are contained and referenced in the Recorded Radar Data Study provided by the NTSB. EWR is sourced as the "impact" speed in the NTSB Radar Data Impact Speed Study due to its close proximity to the WTC, being the most accurate. Remember, this was also cross-checked with video analysis in the NTSB Video Data Impact Speed Study.
The speeds reported are accurate. The speeds reported (along with the maneuvers) during the final portion of flight exceed the capabilities of a standard 767 by a wide margin.
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:06 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Your opinion and beliefs are noted, but have no basis in fact. It seems your "opinions and beliefs" are based on just that... and not the actual data. QUOTE Now you do what you want. Thank you.. we will.. I've been doing it since 2006. QUOTE Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. I can follow somewhat of what you are trying to say... but it is clear you are not able to understand anything I have been trying to tell you. The rest of the people at your reopen911 forum understand our work though... |
|
|
|
Apr 27 2014, 09:02 AM
Post
#3
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 41 Joined: 29-March 08 Member No.: 3,061 |
hello tournesol01
I am not in the position to help you because my knowledge of mathematics has faded somhow and I have no idea of aeronautics, but to get a clue what you are after could you please describe the problem you think you found in the data in simple words, so that a layman gets an idea what this is all about? maybe it is better to write an answer in french, because I also have trouble to understand your english .... |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:01 PM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
lol... that doesn't stop tournesol from giving his two cents... he still thinks a transponder can transmit speed data after I have already given him a source which shows it does not, in any mode... I have forsaken this opinion because I understand now that the speed shown in the PDF data was calculated. But speed can be sent Mode S transponder. You do not tell me if the planes were equipped in 2001. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:46 PM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
No, I calculated the speeds using Lat/long positions of the RADES data. The results are similar to the raw EWR data you have plotted above. However, the end of your curve is not accurate and does not reflect the raw data you have plotted. The last plot of radar data is an estimate plot because he had no primary radar (BO). His position may have some margin. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:28 PM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 02:42 AM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
"This document is derived from computer magnetic recordings of internal computer processing. It is not an exact representation of the control position display." - page 5 of your pdf Emphasis mine... The data in your document also terminates more than 3 mins prior to "impact". Again, transponders do not send speed information. Oh oui ! J'ai mal interprété l'intitulé de ce dernier fichier ! Les vitesses sont effectivement calculées. Je pensais que cette information de vitesse était disponible en mode S. Mais alors, dans ce pdf, pourquoi la vitesse n'est-elle pas calculée jusqu'à la fin du vol ? Oh yes! I misread the title of the last file! The speeds are actually calculated. I thought this information was available speed in S mode But then, in this pdf, why speed is it not calculated until the end of the flight? |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 07:55 AM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I would like to have the opinion who the next person is a member of your association:
Hammish Brannan Former United Kingdom air defense ground enviroment (UKADGE) RADAR technician Primary and secondary ground radar systems ATC & airborne systems (including radio) as an instructor for the Ministry of Defence (MOD) |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:04 PM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:50 PM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
The NY Terminal area is a very busy place serving 6-7 very busy airports in close proximity. Speeds are being assigned to aircraft daily, in real time, so they don't run into each other. I certainly feel very comfortable having more than one radar looking at my airplane when getting vectored for an approach into LGA, JFK, EWR, TEB, HPN... or transitioning to FRG or MMU. yes but the question is why the NTSB not only the nearest radar for its calculations? |
|
|
|
May 2 2014, 03:20 AM
Post
#4
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
hello tournesol01 I am not in the position to help you because my knowledge of mathematics has faded somhow and I have no idea of aeronautics, but to get a clue what you are after could you please describe the problem you think you found in the data in simple words, so that a layman gets an idea what this is all about? maybe it is better to write an answer in french, because I also have trouble to understand your english .... Hello lurker Pour vous répondre, je dis ici dans mes propos que la vitesse donnée par le NTSB est peut-être surévaluée pour cause de précision insuffisante du radar. To answer your question, I said in my remarks here that the speed given by the NTSB may be overstated on grounds of lack accuracy of the radar. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:11 PM
Post
#5
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
But speed can be sent Mode S transponder. Please show me a source which says speed data can be sent via Mode S prior to 9/11/2001. QUOTE No, I do not have these files! The link to the pdf is above. All you have to do is click it. Tournesol01, can you please provide your experience, if any, in aviation? And if none, what experience/education do you have to analyze radar data provided by the NTSB? Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:35 PM
Post
#5
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:57 PM
Post
#5
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
yes but the question is why the NTSB not only the nearest radar for its calculations? They did. The aircraft was moving... so certainly JFK ASR would be useful... along with the other radar facilities in the NY Terminal Area. We are talking about roughly a 30 mile radius around the WTC... many/all of the radar in this area are used to assign speeds to thousands of aircraft per day. And again, the NTSB went even further and did a Video speed study which produced similar results to their radar study. The more data you have, the more accurate the results... yes? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:42 PM
Post
#5
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:57 PM
Post
#5
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
The last plot of radar data is an estimate plot because he had no primary radar (BO). His position may have some margin. The calculations are done with Excel, the formulas are the same for all plots. There is no reason for the last blocks are worse than others. If there is someone you good at math and Excel, I want to share my Excel file and discuss my results and my possible mistakes. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 11:35 AM
Post
#5
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I will begin to explain my point of view:
On the bottom graph are red dots. These are the values of ground speeds calculated from the raw radar data Newark (EWR) Vertical dispersion of these points is elevated when they should be follow up with more regularity, not zigzagging. A plane takes time to change gear. Where does this dispersion? On the one error of less than 1 degree on the azimuth of the radar blips. Playing on the value of the azimuth replace the radar blips in a better configuration and allows to obtain a curve closer to reality speed (the blue dots) Speeds are reduced. Altitude and Range remain the same. The downward slope of the altitude of ual175 flight is nearly constant. Finally, the pilot pushed the engine a short time before impact. Then he may have slowed for the aircraft is not disintegrated before impact. This is my own belief, what do you think of that ? This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 3 2014, 11:37 AM |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:33 PM
Post
#6
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:09 PM
Post
#6
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Tournesol01, can you please provide your experience, if any, in aviation? And if none, what experience/education do you have to analyze radar data provided by the NTSB? So I am 57 years old. I worked 36 years in the French air force. I was technician (installer / repairman) radio / nav in aircraft. I ended my career as researcher in aircraft maintenance. I also worked on the maintenance management of some missiles. I flew alone, very little time on Rally 100hp and glider (WASSMER WA-30 "Bijave") |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:55 PM
Post
#6
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:37 PM
Post
#6
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Please show me a source which says speed data can be sent via Mode S prior to 9/11/2001. Mode S Almost at the end In 2001 I do not know ! This post has been edited by tournesol01: May 7 2014, 04:39 PM |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 01:04 PM
Post
#6
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:01 PM
Post
#6
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
I will begin to explain my point of view: On the bottom graph are red dots. These are the values of ground speeds calculated from the raw radar data Newark (EWR) Those look pretty accurate. I calculated similar results with the RADES data.... it shows the aircraft exceeding 500 knots with values as high as 540 for roughly the last 3 minutes of flight. The NTSB is correct with regard to the speeds reported. Keep in mind, they also used radar from JFK, LGA, and HPN... and also did a Video Speed study with similar results. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 01:07 PM
Post
#6
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
They did. The aircraft was moving... so certainly JFK ASR would be useful... along with the other radar facilities in the NY Terminal Area. We are talking about roughly a 30 mile radius around the WTC... many/all of the radar in this area are used to assign speeds to thousands of aircraft per day. And again, the NTSB went even further and did a Video speed study which produced similar results to their radar study. The more data you have, the more accurate the results... yes? For the final leg I see only two radars, JFK and EWR. I do not know others. For videos, there where the plane is nearer and I think the speed is therefore more accurate. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:42 PM
Post
#7
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Neither of the sources provided via wiki link to a specific source. Please answer my other questions.... |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:49 PM
Post
#7
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. The universal language of aviation is English. Can you read and understand the English language as is required by ICAO and FAA regulations? Or do you need a translator? Forgive me for saying so, but your English is very poor. With that said, my French is even worse. But, if you have a problem understanding and reading the English language without a translator, this may be some of the very problems you are experiencing in your apparent confusion of interpreting the data and details contained within the pdf. Please use English on this forum. This is an English speaking forum. QUOTE Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. This makes no sense as it pertains to the actual data. QUOTE I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. NIST is not an organization involved with Aviation. QUOTE When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. It is not my responsibility to find someone to "criticize" some anonymous guy from France on our forum. We have the data from the NTSB. They are an organization tasked with ensuring the safety of the traveling public. You claim they are wrong. Why should anyone listen to you? Especially considering the fact I have pointed out many errors you have made..... QUOTE For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. This sentence doesn't make much sense to me. Please use proper English as is required by ICAO and FAA standards. QUOTE I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. Your opinion noted. But again, why should anyone listen to you over the NTSB? |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:16 PM
Post
#7
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
The speed curve NTSB is not the same as I got with excel. Have you also tried to reconstruct these curves?
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 01:11 PM
Post
#7
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:14 PM
Post
#7
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
????? !! Where ? Click where, in what ? All sources were posted and linked here.... http://pf911t.org/forum/index.p...&p=10812784 But I will post the most relevant document here again for you... please click on it and read it. http://pf911t.org/radar/Rec_Rad...20_aircraft.pdf So I am 57 years old. I worked 36 years in the French air force. I was technician (installer / repairman) radio / nav in aircraft. I ended my career as researcher in aircraft maintenance. I also worked on the maintenance management of some missiles. I flew alone, very little time on Rally 100hp and glider (WASSMER WA-30 "Bijave") Thank you... but you have a few more questions to answer.... here they are again... Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? When you get done with those.. I will have more.... Also, please try to reply to my post(s) with a single post.... your multiple post replies are eating up our database. Take your time, articulate your thoughts.. .and make one post as a reply. (as a side note.. for those who are reading this from the reopen911 forum, feel free to join in.... it appears JPR, GTO... and a few others understand our work. Tournesol01...??? not so much... perhaps it is just a language barrier?) |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:19 PM
Post
#8
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
The speed curve NTSB is not the same as I got with excel. Have you also tried to reconstruct these curves? No, I calculated the speeds using Lat/long positions of the RADES data. The results are similar to the raw EWR data you have plotted above. However, the end of your curve is not accurate and does not reflect the raw data you have plotted. Again, keep in mind, the NTSB used more than just EWR radar for the speed study. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:39 PM
Post
#9
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
That's what scares me!
Why do not they trust a single radar? With excel I recalculated the latitudes and longitudes of the studs EWR and I did not detect significant difference. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:44 PM
Post
#10
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
That's what scares me! Why do not they trust a single radar? The NY Terminal area is a very busy place serving 6-7 very busy airports in close proximity. Speeds are being assigned to aircraft daily, in real time, so they don't run into each other. I certainly feel very comfortable having more than one radar looking at my airplane when getting vectored for an approach into LGA, JFK, EWR, TEB, HPN... or transitioning to FRG or MMU. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:46 PM
Post
#11
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
No, I calculated the speeds using Lat/long positions of the RADES data. The results are similar to the raw EWR data you have plotted above. However, the end of your curve is not accurate and does not reflect the raw data you have plotted. The last plot of radar data is an estimate plot because he had no primary radar (BO). His position may have some margin. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:50 PM
Post
#12
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
The NY Terminal area is a very busy place serving 6-7 very busy airports in close proximity. Speeds are being assigned to aircraft daily, in real time, so they don't run into each other. I certainly feel very comfortable having more than one radar looking at my airplane when getting vectored for an approach into LGA, JFK, EWR, TEB, HPN... or transitioning to FRG or MMU. yes but the question is why the NTSB not only the nearest radar for its calculations? |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:57 PM
Post
#13
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
yes but the question is why the NTSB not only the nearest radar for its calculations? They did. The aircraft was moving... so certainly JFK ASR would be useful... along with the other radar facilities in the NY Terminal Area. We are talking about roughly a 30 mile radius around the WTC... many/all of the radar in this area are used to assign speeds to thousands of aircraft per day. And again, the NTSB went even further and did a Video speed study which produced similar results to their radar study. The more data you have, the more accurate the results... yes? |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 12:57 PM
Post
#14
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
The last plot of radar data is an estimate plot because he had no primary radar (BO). His position may have some margin. The calculations are done with Excel, the formulas are the same for all plots. There is no reason for the last blocks are worse than others. If there is someone you good at math and Excel, I want to share my Excel file and discuss my results and my possible mistakes. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 01:04 PM
Post
#15
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 01:07 PM
Post
#16
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
They did. The aircraft was moving... so certainly JFK ASR would be useful... along with the other radar facilities in the NY Terminal Area. We are talking about roughly a 30 mile radius around the WTC... many/all of the radar in this area are used to assign speeds to thousands of aircraft per day. And again, the NTSB went even further and did a Video speed study which produced similar results to their radar study. The more data you have, the more accurate the results... yes? For the final leg I see only two radars, JFK and EWR. I do not know others. For videos, there where the plane is nearer and I think the speed is therefore more accurate. |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 01:11 PM
Post
#17
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
Apr 4 2014, 12:57 PM
Post
#18
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
You can adjust the curve by putting values in the "adjust" column Mine are in red in the next column, you can copy them. |
|
|
|
Apr 4 2014, 03:08 PM
Post
#19
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
You can adjust the curve by putting values in the "adjust" column Mine are in red in the next column, you can copy them. |
|
|
|
Apr 4 2014, 07:23 PM
Post
#20
|
|
![]() Group: Respected Member Posts: 1,111 Joined: 7-November 07 From: Prague or France Member No.: 2,452 |
I'm also quite not sure about the end of the curve. The impact speed - as multiple radar analyses and also multiple video analyses (see here, here, here and here) show was quite definitely higher than 470 kts.
If you want to discus this in French, you can contact me via PM - I would think it will be better to keep this forum here in international aviation language - the English. Si tu veux discuter ca en français, tu peux me contacter par PM - Je pense que ca sera mieux tenir cet forum ici en la lague de l'aviation internationale - L'anglais |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 05:47 AM
Post
#21
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Bonjour.
Y a t'il quelqu'un pour parler en français et me traduire. C'est pour exposer mes travaux sur l'étude des données radar de Newark. Je trouve qu'elles peuvent être plus basses que cela a été écrit par le NTSB. |
|
|
|
Apr 27 2014, 01:40 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Sorry for my english, but this is a translation in line with translate.google.fr
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:02 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Now you do what you want. Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. |
|
|
|
Apr 20 2014, 04:55 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Has anyone tried my Excel file?
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 12:51 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Ok ! What time begins for you, the final portion of flight ?
This post has been edited by tournesol01: May 7 2014, 12:54 PM |
|
|
|
Apr 22 2014, 08:54 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
For simplicity, an electromagnetic wave emitted from an antenna consisting of a simple vertical mast , as the wave propagates created by dropping a pebble in water.
We observe concentric waves that move away from the place where the stone was " splash " For a radar antenna , one should consider, at time t , a sector oriented , more or less wide , previous concentric circles. Radar sprinkles its electromagnetic wave while a sector simultaneously. If a boat replaces here the plane , when the wave will reach , its location is random in the sector . However , the azimuth radar is necessarily that given by the determined angle between the geographic North and the angle bisector of the sector oriented when the wave reaches the boat . The boat can be at the right or left of the bisector , we have here a correction to find the actual azimuth of the boat. Bringing to a more realistic azimuth angle changes the distance between the radar blips . It is found that with a speed increased so that one side and down the other . This is what I want to convey in my Excel file.
This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 22 2014, 08:56 AM |
|
|
|
May 3 2014, 12:58 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Active Forum Pilot Posts: 477 Joined: 16-August 07 From: Upstate NY/VT border Member No.: 1,719 |
May we please see the UA175 speed data source?
|
|
|
|
Apr 17 2014, 07:00 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I added more blocks to my Excel file.
For now here are their geographic positions:
|
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 04:45 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
![]() La précision requise pour un calcul de vitesse est insuffisante. Au mieux avec un écart max de +/- .7° par rapport à l'axe du lobe principal, la marge d'erreur est de 140 kts! Et encore, il faut pour cela être à moins de 10 miles nautique du radar. ASR-9 et ARSR-4 ont la même imprécision. The precision required for a calculation speed is low. At best with a maximum deviation of + / - .7 ° relative to the axis of the main lobe, the margin of error is 140 kts! And again, this requires to be less than 10 nautical miles from the radar. ASR-9 and ARSR-4 have the same vagueness. |
|
|
|
May 4 2014, 01:24 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 08:19 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Sinon, le NTSB aurait repris des données du même style et les aurait communiquées telles quelles.
Otherwise, the NTSB would have taken data of the same style and would have communicated as is. |
|
|
|
Apr 28 2014, 10:08 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
By what means the NTSB as smoothed the curve?
The blue curve is the curve without retouching
|
|
|
|
Apr 6 2014, 12:13 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Could someone tell me if he tried my excel table and what he thinks?
I want to know this smooth curve is envisagable as compulsorily older credible, realistic approach and that we must consider. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:19 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 41 Joined: 29-March 08 Member No.: 3,061 |
thankyou rob and tournesol01 for your interesting discussion!
I am sorry I can't contribute anything useful because I am lacking knowledge in this field. But I just wonder why in the pdf-file linked above (http://unique.annonce.free.fr/downloads/Plot_transpondeur_UAL175_CDR.pdf) are 2 pages (p 2,3) "transmission verification report", where the first shows the date "09/06/2001" ... But also, as an IT professional I am curious to learn why "magnetic recordings of internal computer processing" could in any way NOT represent an accurate representation of the data received, processed and stored during computer processing? The second sentence in this paragraph (p 5) I think relates to "the document" you look at, not the data ... |
|
|
|
May 2 2014, 08:33 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
Apr 22 2014, 11:44 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I would like to discuss with him my theory ! This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 22 2014, 11:47 AM |
|
|
|
May 1 2014, 03:15 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Si quelqu'un parmis vous pouvait me dire le type, la marque et la précision en azimut du radar de Newark en 2001, je pourrais continuer ma démarche......
J'ai mis, pour obtenir ce graphe une précision de +/-0,3° et la courbe donnée par le NTSB tombe en dessous dans les dernières secondes. Pourquoi ? If anyone among you could tell me the type, brand and azimuth accuracy of radar Newark in 2001, I could continue my approach ...... I put, for this graph an accuracy of + / -0.3 ° and the curve given by the NTSB falls below in the final seconds. Why? Visiblement, c'est une hérésie de ce servir d'un radar pour établir la vitesse d'un avion ! Obviously, this is a heresy that used radar to determine the speed of an airplane ! ![]() ![]() Vous pouvez dans ce fichier entrer la valeur de précision de votre choix. Merci de bien vouloir critiquer mon travail et de me donner les corrections à appliquer si vous trouvez des mauvais calculs. You can in this file enter the value of precision of your choice. Thank you kindly to critique my work and give me the corrections to be applied if you find any miscalculations. Fichier Excel |
|
|
|
Apr 25 2014, 09:24 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Speed is too high, then it is not a usual plane that hit the WTC Rather than: A boeing hit the WTC but the speed given by the NTSB may be overstated It is still easier and convincing to believe miscalculations than seeking shenanigans with aircraft doctored, right? This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 25 2014, 09:25 AM |
|
|
|
Apr 26 2014, 02:30 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I can still show you that I do not do just about anything with the data NTSB:
This post has been edited by tournesol01: Apr 26 2014, 02:32 PM |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:36 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Si c'est à cause d'un radar trop éloigné que la vitesse n'a pas été calculée jusqu'au bout, c'est bien que la précision doit faire défaut, non ?
If this is due to a radar too far as speed was not calculated until the end, it is that the accuracy is lacking, right? |
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 05:33 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 03:45 PM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Un contrôleur aérien doit maintenir les avions, dont il a la charge, espacés d'au moins trois miles nautiques. Cet espace est très supérieur à un écart dû à la précision du radar.
Qu'il n'y est pas d'incident est donc normal. An air traffic controller must maintain the aircraft, which he is responsible, spaced at least three nautical miles. This space is greater than a difference caused by the precision of the radar. That there is no incident is normal. Les vitesses qui sont calculées, oui ! En théorie, mais je sais qu'un avion ne vole plus en dessous de sa vitesse de décrochage. Speeds that are calculated , yes! In theory, but I know a plane stops flying below its stall speed. NON ! Les vitesses affichées sur les écrans radar sont celles envoyées par le transpondeur ! Il n'y a pas, dans ce cas, de calculs à effectuer. Je ne sais pas si une vitesse s'affiche si le transpondeur est en mode 3/A. A vous de me le dire !! NO ! The speeds displayed on the radar screens are those sent by the transponder ! There is not , in this case , to perform calculations . I do not know if speed is displayed if the transponder is in mode 3 / A. You tell me ! |
|
|
|
Apr 19 2014, 05:36 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Some tell me that I must take into account several radars to get a more accurate curve.
This is impossible with the uncertainty of the timestamp between two different radars. In addition, provide additional points on a curve, then they will also be scattered will only increase the possibilities to draw a curve. It is better to make a curve of each radar and compare the results. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 09:04 AM
Post
#22
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:06 PM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Your opinion and beliefs are noted, but have no basis in fact. It seems your "opinions and beliefs" are based on just that... and not the actual data. QUOTE Now you do what you want. Thank you.. we will.. I've been doing it since 2006. QUOTE Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. I can follow somewhat of what you are trying to say... but it is clear you are not able to understand anything I have been trying to tell you. The rest of the people at your reopen911 forum understand our work though... |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 11:48 AM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
JFK, EWR, HPN, SWF and RADES radar were all used in determining aircraft performance (speed) during the final portion of flight (not just 'impact'). The details and files are contained and referenced in the Recorded Radar Data Study provided by the NTSB. EWR is sourced as the "impact" speed in the NTSB Radar Data Impact Speed Study due to its close proximity to the WTC, being the most accurate. Remember, this was also cross-checked with video analysis in the NTSB Video Data Impact Speed Study.
The speeds reported are accurate. The speeds reported (along with the maneuvers) during the final portion of flight exceed the capabilities of a standard 767 by a wide margin.
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:06 PM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 05:41 PM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
"This document is derived from computer magnetic recordings of internal computer processing. It is not an exact representation of the control position display." - page 5 of your pdf Emphasis mine... The data in your document also terminates more than 3 mins prior to "impact". Again, transponders do not send speed information. |
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 04:23 PM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
NO ! The speeds displayed on the radar screens are those sent by the transponder ! Really? Can you please tell me what type of transponder sends speed information? QUOTE I do not know if speed is displayed if the transponder is in mode 3 / A. You tell me ! Speed is displayed to ATC based on distance/time calculations made by the Radar hardware itself in real time and is constantly updating. The transponder does not send speed information. Read and learn... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_tran...de_A_and_Mode_C "UA175" was squawking Mode C throughout its entire flight... although the squawk code was changed... (according to the official story). Your speed margins for error are absurd. If such margins existed, planes would be running into each other daily at every major hub across the globe. Again, the speeds reported by the NTSB have been cross-checked using several different radar facilities and video analysis. The speeds reported by the NTSB are accurate. The speeds reported (both yours and the NTSB) exceed the performance of a standard 767 by a wide margin. |
|
|
|
May 5 2014, 08:11 PM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
A boeing hit the WTC but the speed given by the NTSB may be overstated The speeds you have calculated, reaching 540 knots... and closing at nearly 500 knots. (in which you admit you may have made errors), are still too excessive for a standard Boeing 767 based on precedent.... ![]() With that said, when cross-checking the various radar data, the NTSB, and their video speed study, the NTSB calculations are accurate. |
|
|
|
Apr 27 2014, 09:02 AM
Post
#23
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 41 Joined: 29-March 08 Member No.: 3,061 |
hello tournesol01
I am not in the position to help you because my knowledge of mathematics has faded somhow and I have no idea of aeronautics, but to get a clue what you are after could you please describe the problem you think you found in the data in simple words, so that a layman gets an idea what this is all about? maybe it is better to write an answer in french, because I also have trouble to understand your english .... |
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 04:48 AM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
The precision required for a calculation speed is low. At best with a maximum deviation of + / - .7 ° relative to the axis of the main lobe, the margin of error is 140 kts! With such a large margin for error... (according to you) how can thousands of aircraft possibly arrive and depart the NYC terminal Area safely each day with speed assignments referenced from ASR radar in real time? QUOTE the margin of error is 140 kts! Just so we have this clear. You are saying that the speeds reported could be in error as much as 650 kts... and as low as 370 kts? And that those who are assigned speeds using ASR radar.... for example.. ATC assigns 200 knots upon arrival into JFK..... but really NY TRACON would be seeing as much as 340 knots or as low as 60 knots on their ASR screens? Really? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:33 PM
Post
#23
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
thankyou rob and tournesol01 for your interesting discussion! I am sorry I can't contribute anything useful because I am lacking knowledge in this field. lol... that doesn't stop tournesol from giving his two cents... he still thinks a transponder can transmit speed data after I have already given him a source which shows it does not, in any mode... QUOTE But I just wonder why in the pdf-file linked above (http://unique.annonce.free.fr/downloads/Plot_transpondeur_UAL175_CDR.pdf) are 2 pages (p 2,3) "transmission verification report", where the first shows the date "09/06/2001" ... Yes, that is interesting.... I noticed that too. The two pages are from different fax machines.. .so the first inaccurate date could be explained by an incorrect date setting on that particular machine. QUOTE But also, as an IT professional I am curious to learn why "magnetic recordings of internal computer processing" could in any way NOT represent an accurate representation of the data received, processed and stored during computer processing? The second sentence in this paragraph (p 5) I think relates to "the document" you look at, not the data ... I think they were referencing the graphic itself since it shows some offsets. If the date/time on page 3 is accurate (09/11/2001 1607... im assuming in Zulu), the fax was sent only hours after the events.. so clearly the data was a preliminary rough output. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:04 PM
Post
#24
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 02:42 AM
Post
#24
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
"This document is derived from computer magnetic recordings of internal computer processing. It is not an exact representation of the control position display." - page 5 of your pdf Emphasis mine... The data in your document also terminates more than 3 mins prior to "impact". Again, transponders do not send speed information. Oh oui ! J'ai mal interprété l'intitulé de ce dernier fichier ! Les vitesses sont effectivement calculées. Je pensais que cette information de vitesse était disponible en mode S. Mais alors, dans ce pdf, pourquoi la vitesse n'est-elle pas calculée jusqu'à la fin du vol ? Oh yes! I misread the title of the last file! The speeds are actually calculated. I thought this information was available speed in S mode But then, in this pdf, why speed is it not calculated until the end of the flight? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:01 PM
Post
#24
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
lol... that doesn't stop tournesol from giving his two cents... he still thinks a transponder can transmit speed data after I have already given him a source which shows it does not, in any mode... I have forsaken this opinion because I understand now that the speed shown in the PDF data was calculated. But speed can be sent Mode S transponder. You do not tell me if the planes were equipped in 2001. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:28 PM
Post
#24
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 2 2014, 03:20 AM
Post
#24
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
hello tournesol01 I am not in the position to help you because my knowledge of mathematics has faded somhow and I have no idea of aeronautics, but to get a clue what you are after could you please describe the problem you think you found in the data in simple words, so that a layman gets an idea what this is all about? maybe it is better to write an answer in french, because I also have trouble to understand your english .... Hello lurker Pour vous répondre, je dis ici dans mes propos que la vitesse donnée par le NTSB est peut-être surévaluée pour cause de précision insuffisante du radar. To answer your question, I said in my remarks here that the speed given by the NTSB may be overstated on grounds of lack accuracy of the radar. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:35 PM
Post
#25
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:42 PM
Post
#25
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:11 PM
Post
#25
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
But speed can be sent Mode S transponder. Please show me a source which says speed data can be sent via Mode S prior to 9/11/2001. QUOTE No, I do not have these files! The link to the pdf is above. All you have to do is click it. Tournesol01, can you please provide your experience, if any, in aviation? And if none, what experience/education do you have to analyze radar data provided by the NTSB? Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:55 PM
Post
#26
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:37 PM
Post
#26
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Please show me a source which says speed data can be sent via Mode S prior to 9/11/2001. Mode S Almost at the end In 2001 I do not know ! This post has been edited by tournesol01: May 7 2014, 04:39 PM |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:33 PM
Post
#26
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:09 PM
Post
#26
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Tournesol01, can you please provide your experience, if any, in aviation? And if none, what experience/education do you have to analyze radar data provided by the NTSB? So I am 57 years old. I worked 36 years in the French air force. I was technician (installer / repairman) radio / nav in aircraft. I ended my career as researcher in aircraft maintenance. I also worked on the maintenance management of some missiles. I flew alone, very little time on Rally 100hp and glider (WASSMER WA-30 "Bijave") |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:14 PM
Post
#27
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
????? !! Where ? Click where, in what ? All sources were posted and linked here.... http://pf911t.org/forum/index.p...&p=10812784 But I will post the most relevant document here again for you... please click on it and read it. http://pf911t.org/radar/Rec_Rad...20_aircraft.pdf So I am 57 years old. I worked 36 years in the French air force. I was technician (installer / repairman) radio / nav in aircraft. I ended my career as researcher in aircraft maintenance. I also worked on the maintenance management of some missiles. I flew alone, very little time on Rally 100hp and glider (WASSMER WA-30 "Bijave") Thank you... but you have a few more questions to answer.... here they are again... Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? When you get done with those.. I will have more.... Also, please try to reply to my post(s) with a single post.... your multiple post replies are eating up our database. Take your time, articulate your thoughts.. .and make one post as a reply. (as a side note.. for those who are reading this from the reopen911 forum, feel free to join in.... it appears JPR, GTO... and a few others understand our work. Tournesol01...??? not so much... perhaps it is just a language barrier?) |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:49 PM
Post
#27
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. The universal language of aviation is English. Can you read and understand the English language as is required by ICAO and FAA regulations? Or do you need a translator? Forgive me for saying so, but your English is very poor. With that said, my French is even worse. But, if you have a problem understanding and reading the English language without a translator, this may be some of the very problems you are experiencing in your apparent confusion of interpreting the data and details contained within the pdf. Please use English on this forum. This is an English speaking forum. QUOTE Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. This makes no sense as it pertains to the actual data. QUOTE I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. NIST is not an organization involved with Aviation. QUOTE When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. It is not my responsibility to find someone to "criticize" some anonymous guy from France on our forum. We have the data from the NTSB. They are an organization tasked with ensuring the safety of the traveling public. You claim they are wrong. Why should anyone listen to you? Especially considering the fact I have pointed out many errors you have made..... QUOTE For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. This sentence doesn't make much sense to me. Please use proper English as is required by ICAO and FAA standards. QUOTE I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. Your opinion noted. But again, why should anyone listen to you over the NTSB? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:42 PM
Post
#27
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Neither of the sources provided via wiki link to a specific source. Please answer my other questions.... |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 05:47 AM
Post
#41
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Bonjour.
Y a t'il quelqu'un pour parler en français et me traduire. C'est pour exposer mes travaux sur l'étude des données radar de Newark. Je trouve qu'elles peuvent être plus basses que cela a été écrit par le NTSB. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 09:04 AM
Post
#42
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:02 PM
Post
#42
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Now you do what you want. Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:36 AM
Post
#42
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Si c'est à cause d'un radar trop éloigné que la vitesse n'a pas été calculée jusqu'au bout, c'est bien que la précision doit faire défaut, non ?
If this is due to a radar too far as speed was not calculated until the end, it is that the accuracy is lacking, right? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 08:19 AM
Post
#42
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Sinon, le NTSB aurait repris des données du même style et les aurait communiquées telles quelles.
Otherwise, the NTSB would have taken data of the same style and would have communicated as is. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:19 PM
Post
#42
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 41 Joined: 29-March 08 Member No.: 3,061 |
thankyou rob and tournesol01 for your interesting discussion!
I am sorry I can't contribute anything useful because I am lacking knowledge in this field. But I just wonder why in the pdf-file linked above (http://unique.annonce.free.fr/downloads/Plot_transpondeur_UAL175_CDR.pdf) are 2 pages (p 2,3) "transmission verification report", where the first shows the date "09/06/2001" ... But also, as an IT professional I am curious to learn why "magnetic recordings of internal computer processing" could in any way NOT represent an accurate representation of the data received, processed and stored during computer processing? The second sentence in this paragraph (p 5) I think relates to "the document" you look at, not the data ... |
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 05:33 PM
Post
#42
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 12:51 PM
Post
#42
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Ok ! What time begins for you, the final portion of flight ?
This post has been edited by tournesol01: May 7 2014, 12:54 PM |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:06 PM
Post
#43
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Your opinion and beliefs are noted, but have no basis in fact. It seems your "opinions and beliefs" are based on just that... and not the actual data. QUOTE Now you do what you want. Thank you.. we will.. I've been doing it since 2006. QUOTE Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. I can follow somewhat of what you are trying to say... but it is clear you are not able to understand anything I have been trying to tell you. The rest of the people at your reopen911 forum understand our work though... |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:06 PM
Post
#43
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 11:48 AM
Post
#43
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
JFK, EWR, HPN, SWF and RADES radar were all used in determining aircraft performance (speed) during the final portion of flight (not just 'impact'). The details and files are contained and referenced in the Recorded Radar Data Study provided by the NTSB. EWR is sourced as the "impact" speed in the NTSB Radar Data Impact Speed Study due to its close proximity to the WTC, being the most accurate. Remember, this was also cross-checked with video analysis in the NTSB Video Data Impact Speed Study.
The speeds reported are accurate. The speeds reported (along with the maneuvers) during the final portion of flight exceed the capabilities of a standard 767 by a wide margin.
|
|
|
|
May 6 2014, 05:41 PM
Post
#43
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
"This document is derived from computer magnetic recordings of internal computer processing. It is not an exact representation of the control position display." - page 5 of your pdf Emphasis mine... The data in your document also terminates more than 3 mins prior to "impact". Again, transponders do not send speed information. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 01:33 PM
Post
#43
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
thankyou rob and tournesol01 for your interesting discussion! I am sorry I can't contribute anything useful because I am lacking knowledge in this field. lol... that doesn't stop tournesol from giving his two cents... he still thinks a transponder can transmit speed data after I have already given him a source which shows it does not, in any mode... QUOTE But I just wonder why in the pdf-file linked above (http://unique.annonce.free.fr/downloads/Plot_transpondeur_UAL175_CDR.pdf) are 2 pages (p 2,3) "transmission verification report", where the first shows the date "09/06/2001" ... Yes, that is interesting.... I noticed that too. The two pages are from different fax machines.. .so the first inaccurate date could be explained by an incorrect date setting on that particular machine. QUOTE But also, as an IT professional I am curious to learn why "magnetic recordings of internal computer processing" could in any way NOT represent an accurate representation of the data received, processed and stored during computer processing? The second sentence in this paragraph (p 5) I think relates to "the document" you look at, not the data ... I think they were referencing the graphic itself since it shows some offsets. If the date/time on page 3 is accurate (09/11/2001 1607... im assuming in Zulu), the fax was sent only hours after the events.. so clearly the data was a preliminary rough output. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:28 PM
Post
#44
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:01 PM
Post
#44
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
lol... that doesn't stop tournesol from giving his two cents... he still thinks a transponder can transmit speed data after I have already given him a source which shows it does not, in any mode... I have forsaken this opinion because I understand now that the speed shown in the PDF data was calculated. But speed can be sent Mode S transponder. You do not tell me if the planes were equipped in 2001. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:04 PM
Post
#44
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 02:42 AM
Post
#44
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
"This document is derived from computer magnetic recordings of internal computer processing. It is not an exact representation of the control position display." - page 5 of your pdf Emphasis mine... The data in your document also terminates more than 3 mins prior to "impact". Again, transponders do not send speed information. Oh oui ! J'ai mal interprété l'intitulé de ce dernier fichier ! Les vitesses sont effectivement calculées. Je pensais que cette information de vitesse était disponible en mode S. Mais alors, dans ce pdf, pourquoi la vitesse n'est-elle pas calculée jusqu'à la fin du vol ? Oh yes! I misread the title of the last file! The speeds are actually calculated. I thought this information was available speed in S mode But then, in this pdf, why speed is it not calculated until the end of the flight? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:35 PM
Post
#45
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 03:11 PM
Post
#45
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
But speed can be sent Mode S transponder. Please show me a source which says speed data can be sent via Mode S prior to 9/11/2001. QUOTE No, I do not have these files! The link to the pdf is above. All you have to do is click it. Tournesol01, can you please provide your experience, if any, in aviation? And if none, what experience/education do you have to analyze radar data provided by the NTSB? Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:42 PM
Post
#45
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:33 PM
Post
#46
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:55 PM
Post
#46
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:09 PM
Post
#46
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Tournesol01, can you please provide your experience, if any, in aviation? And if none, what experience/education do you have to analyze radar data provided by the NTSB? So I am 57 years old. I worked 36 years in the French air force. I was technician (installer / repairman) radio / nav in aircraft. I ended my career as researcher in aircraft maintenance. I also worked on the maintenance management of some missiles. I flew alone, very little time on Rally 100hp and glider (WASSMER WA-30 "Bijave") |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:37 PM
Post
#46
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Please show me a source which says speed data can be sent via Mode S prior to 9/11/2001. Mode S Almost at the end In 2001 I do not know ! This post has been edited by tournesol01: May 7 2014, 04:39 PM |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:49 PM
Post
#47
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. The universal language of aviation is English. Can you read and understand the English language as is required by ICAO and FAA regulations? Or do you need a translator? Forgive me for saying so, but your English is very poor. With that said, my French is even worse. But, if you have a problem understanding and reading the English language without a translator, this may be some of the very problems you are experiencing in your apparent confusion of interpreting the data and details contained within the pdf. Please use English on this forum. This is an English speaking forum. QUOTE Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. This makes no sense as it pertains to the actual data. QUOTE I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. NIST is not an organization involved with Aviation. QUOTE When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. It is not my responsibility to find someone to "criticize" some anonymous guy from France on our forum. We have the data from the NTSB. They are an organization tasked with ensuring the safety of the traveling public. You claim they are wrong. Why should anyone listen to you? Especially considering the fact I have pointed out many errors you have made..... QUOTE For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. This sentence doesn't make much sense to me. Please use proper English as is required by ICAO and FAA standards. QUOTE I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. Your opinion noted. But again, why should anyone listen to you over the NTSB? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:14 PM
Post
#47
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
????? !! Where ? Click where, in what ? All sources were posted and linked here.... http://pf911t.org/forum/index.p...&p=10812784 But I will post the most relevant document here again for you... please click on it and read it. http://pf911t.org/radar/Rec_Rad...20_aircraft.pdf So I am 57 years old. I worked 36 years in the French air force. I was technician (installer / repairman) radio / nav in aircraft. I ended my career as researcher in aircraft maintenance. I also worked on the maintenance management of some missiles. I flew alone, very little time on Rally 100hp and glider (WASSMER WA-30 "Bijave") Thank you... but you have a few more questions to answer.... here they are again... Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? When you get done with those.. I will have more.... Also, please try to reply to my post(s) with a single post.... your multiple post replies are eating up our database. Take your time, articulate your thoughts.. .and make one post as a reply. (as a side note.. for those who are reading this from the reopen911 forum, feel free to join in.... it appears JPR, GTO... and a few others understand our work. Tournesol01...??? not so much... perhaps it is just a language barrier?) |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 04:42 PM
Post
#47
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Neither of the sources provided via wiki link to a specific source. Please answer my other questions.... |
|
|
|
Apr 3 2014, 05:47 AM
Post
#61
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Bonjour.
Y a t'il quelqu'un pour parler en français et me traduire. C'est pour exposer mes travaux sur l'étude des données radar de Newark. Je trouve qu'elles peuvent être plus basses que cela a été écrit par le NTSB. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:14 PM
Post
#61
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
????? !! Where ? Click where, in what ? All sources were posted and linked here.... http://pf911t.org/forum/index.p...&p=10812784 But I will post the most relevant document here again for you... please click on it and read it. http://pf911t.org/radar/Rec_Rad...20_aircraft.pdf So I am 57 years old. I worked 36 years in the French air force. I was technician (installer / repairman) radio / nav in aircraft. I ended my career as researcher in aircraft maintenance. I also worked on the maintenance management of some missiles. I flew alone, very little time on Rally 100hp and glider (WASSMER WA-30 "Bijave") Thank you... but you have a few more questions to answer.... here they are again... Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? When you get done with those.. I will have more.... Also, please try to reply to my post(s) with a single post.... your multiple post replies are eating up our database. Take your time, articulate your thoughts.. .and make one post as a reply. (as a side note.. for those who are reading this from the reopen911 forum, feel free to join in.... it appears JPR, GTO... and a few others understand our work. Tournesol01...??? not so much... perhaps it is just a language barrier?) |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:33 PM
Post
#62
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
Do you still feel the margin of error could be as much as 140 knots? Have you reviewed the Video Data Impact Speed Study? Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:02 PM
Post
#62
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Now you do what you want. Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 05:49 PM
Post
#63
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Oui mais c'est une marge théorique qui ne tient pas compte des limites de vol des avions quels qu'ils soient. Elle n'est valable que sur un radar à la fois. J'ai bien regardé le Video Data Impact Speed Study. Je cherche l'étude du NIST où la vidéo à l'air plus nette. Quand allez vous me trouver quelqu'un pour discuter et critiquer la facon dont sont faits mes calculs. Car enfin, si personne chez vous n'étudie ma méthode pour dire "oui, ces calculs sont censés" ou "non, c'est n'importe quoi", ce n'est pas la peine de continuer. Moi je trouve ambarassant de ne pas savoir comment le NTSB a calculé la vitesse sur la courbe finale sans annoncer une marge d'erreur. The universal language of aviation is English. Can you read and understand the English language as is required by ICAO and FAA regulations? Or do you need a translator? Forgive me for saying so, but your English is very poor. With that said, my French is even worse. But, if you have a problem understanding and reading the English language without a translator, this may be some of the very problems you are experiencing in your apparent confusion of interpreting the data and details contained within the pdf. Please use English on this forum. This is an English speaking forum. QUOTE Yes, but it is a theoretical margin ignores the limits of aircraft flight whatsoever. It is valid only for a radar at a time. This makes no sense as it pertains to the actual data. QUOTE I watched the Video Data Impact Speed Study. Looking for the NIST study where the video looks more clear. NIST is not an organization involved with Aviation. QUOTE When will you find me someone to discuss and criticize the way in which my calculations are made. It is not my responsibility to find someone to "criticize" some anonymous guy from France on our forum. We have the data from the NTSB. They are an organization tasked with ensuring the safety of the traveling public. You claim they are wrong. Why should anyone listen to you? Especially considering the fact I have pointed out many errors you have made..... QUOTE For if person you are studying my way to say "yes, these calculations are supposed to" or "no, it was not anything," it is not worth continuing. This sentence doesn't make much sense to me. Please use proper English as is required by ICAO and FAA standards. QUOTE I found ambarassant not know how the NTSB calculated speed on the final curve without announcing a margin of error. Your opinion noted. But again, why should anyone listen to you over the NTSB? |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:06 PM
Post
#63
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Your opinion and beliefs are noted, but have no basis in fact. It seems your "opinions and beliefs" are based on just that... and not the actual data. QUOTE Now you do what you want. Thank you.. we will.. I've been doing it since 2006. QUOTE Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. I can follow somewhat of what you are trying to say... but it is clear you are not able to understand anything I have been trying to tell you. The rest of the people at your reopen911 forum understand our work though... |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:02 PM
Post
#64
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Now you do what you want. Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:28 PM
Post
#64
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:06 PM
Post
#65
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
I gave my opinion and beliefs. Your opinion and beliefs are noted, but have no basis in fact. It seems your "opinions and beliefs" are based on just that... and not the actual data. QUOTE Now you do what you want. Thank you.. we will.. I've been doing it since 2006. QUOTE Sorry for my english not aeronautics, but I am unable match without translate. It is still a big effort communication on my part. I can follow somewhat of what you are trying to say... but it is clear you are not able to understand anything I have been trying to tell you. The rest of the people at your reopen911 forum understand our work though... |
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:35 PM
Post
#65
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:28 PM
Post
#66
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 45 Joined: 2-April 14 Member No.: 7,759 |
|
|
|
|
May 7 2014, 06:35 PM
Post
#67
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
|
|
|
|
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:19 PM |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:22 PM |
![]() ![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:18 PM |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:16 PM |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 08:49 AM |
![]() ![]() |
![]() |
![]() ![]() |
![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:20 PM |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:21 PM |
![]() |
![]() ![]() |
Speed Ground Ual175, Le calcul des vitesses par le NTSB |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:23 PM |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 10:17 PM |
tournesol01 Speed Ground Ual175 Apr 3 2014, 05:47 AM
tournesol01 Good morning.
Is there someone to speak French a... Apr 3 2014, 06:20 AM
tournesol01 Here is what I propose as speed curve: Apr 3 2014, 06:42 AM
tournesol01 I would like to have the opinion who the next pers... Apr 3 2014, 07:55 AM
tournesol01 I will begin to explain my point of view:
On the... Apr 3 2014, 11:35 AM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 3 2014, 11:35 AM... Apr 3 2014, 12:01 PM
tournesol01 The speed curve NTSB is not the same as I got with... Apr 3 2014, 12:16 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 3 2014, 12:16 PM... Apr 3 2014, 12:19 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ Apr 3 2014, 05:19 PM... Apr 3 2014, 12:46 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 3 2014, 05:46 PM... Apr 3 2014, 12:57 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 3 2014, 12:57 PM... Apr 3 2014, 01:04 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ Apr 3 2014, 06:04 PM... Apr 3 2014, 01:11 PM
tournesol01 That's what scares me!
Why do not they tr... Apr 3 2014, 12:39 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 3 2014, 12:39 PM... Apr 3 2014, 12:44 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ Apr 3 2014, 05:44 PM... Apr 3 2014, 12:50 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 3 2014, 12:50 PM... Apr 3 2014, 12:57 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ Apr 3 2014, 05:57 PM... Apr 3 2014, 01:07 PM
tournesol01 Speed UAL175
You can adjust the curve by putting ... Apr 4 2014, 12:57 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 4 2014, 05:57 PM... Apr 4 2014, 03:08 PM
tumetuestumefaisdubien I'm also quite not sure about the end of the c... Apr 4 2014, 07:23 PM
tournesol01 Could someone tell me if he tried my excel table a... Apr 6 2014, 12:13 PM
tournesol01 I added more blocks to my Excel file.
For now her... Apr 17 2014, 07:00 AM
tournesol01 Some tell me that I must take into account several... Apr 19 2014, 05:36 AM
tournesol01 Has anyone tried my Excel file? Apr 20 2014, 04:55 AM
tournesol01 For simplicity, an electromagnetic wave emitted fr... Apr 22 2014, 08:54 AM
tournesol01 Mr Balsamo, could you contact for me the member of... Apr 22 2014, 11:44 AM
tournesol01 Why do you prefer to say:
Speed is ... Apr 25 2014, 09:24 AM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ Apr 25 2014, 09:24 A... May 5 2014, 08:11 PM
tournesol01 I can still show you that I do not do just about a... Apr 26 2014, 02:30 PM
lurker hello tournesol01
I am not in the position to hel... Apr 27 2014, 09:02 AM
tournesol01 QUOTE (lurker @ Apr 27 2014, 02:02 PM) he... May 2 2014, 03:20 AM
tournesol01 Sorry for my english, but this is a translation in... Apr 27 2014, 01:40 PM
tournesol01 By what means the NTSB as smoothed the curve?
The ... Apr 28 2014, 10:08 AM
tournesol01 Si quelqu'un parmis vous pouvait me dire le ty... May 1 2014, 03:15 PM
tournesol01 RE: Speed Ground Ual175 May 2 2014, 08:33 AM
kawika May we please see the UA175 speed data source? May 3 2014, 12:58 PM
tournesol01 Yes, this is the source FAA:
4-n90-67-plot-printo... May 4 2014, 01:24 PM
tournesol01 La précision requise pour un calcul de vitesse est... May 6 2014, 04:45 AM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 6 2014, 04:45 AM... May 6 2014, 04:48 AM
tournesol01 Un contrôleur aérien doit maintenir les avions, do... May 6 2014, 03:45 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 6 2014, 03:45 PM... May 6 2014, 04:23 PM
tournesol01 alt, hdg, speed May 6 2014, 05:33 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 6 2014, 05:33 PM... May 6 2014, 05:41 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 6 2014, 10:41 PM... May 7 2014, 02:42 AM
tournesol01 Si c'est à cause d'un radar trop éloigné q... May 7 2014, 04:36 AM
tournesol01 Sinon, le NTSB aurait repris des données du même s... May 7 2014, 08:19 AM
tournesol01 RE: Speed Ground Ual175 May 7 2014, 09:04 AM
rob balsamo JFK, EWR, HPN, SWF and RADES radar were all used i... May 7 2014, 11:48 AM
tournesol01 Ok ! What time begins for you, the final porti... May 7 2014, 12:51 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 12:51 PM... May 7 2014, 01:06 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 7 2014, 06:06 PM... May 7 2014, 03:04 PM
lurker thankyou rob and tournesol01 for your interesting ... May 7 2014, 01:19 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (lurker @ May 7 2014, 01:19 PM) tha... May 7 2014, 01:33 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 7 2014, 06:33 PM... May 7 2014, 03:01 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 03:01 PM... May 7 2014, 03:11 PM

tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 7 2014, 08:11 PM... May 7 2014, 04:37 PM


rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 04:37 PM... May 7 2014, 04:42 PM

tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 7 2014, 08:11 PM... May 7 2014, 04:55 PM

tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 7 2014, 08:11 PM... May 7 2014, 05:09 PM


rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 04:55 PM... May 7 2014, 05:14 PM

tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 7 2014, 08:11 PM... May 7 2014, 05:33 PM

rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 05:33 PM... May 7 2014, 05:49 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 08:01 PM... May 7 2014, 04:42 PM
tournesol01 I gave my opinion and beliefs.
Now you do what yo... May 7 2014, 06:02 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 06:02 PM... May 7 2014, 06:06 PM
tournesol01 QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 7 2014, 11:06 PM... May 7 2014, 06:28 PM
rob balsamo QUOTE (tournesol01 @ May 7 2014, 06:28 PM... May 7 2014, 06:35 PMSource file links: