title 'Strange Transponder Data -' contains 12 files, 80 entries, 11 unique posts
May 28 2008, 01:25 PM
Post
#1
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 7 Joined: 14-December 06 Member No.: 320 |
Some expert advice is requested here;
http://s1.zetaboards.com/LooseChangeForums...c/304879/1/#new Any comments are greatly appreciated. MM |
|
|
|
May 28 2008, 10:24 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Long time no see MM.. .good to see ya..
Not really sure what JFK is trying to get at, but nothing looks "out of the ordinary" in his screenshots. AA11 was assigned a squawk and the transponder was turned off. UA175 was also assigned a squawk, and from what i understand, UA175 transponder code was changed, the transponder was never turned off. Keep in mind, all the above is according to the govt story. Tell JFK i said you're welcome.. and also tell him to stop holding a grudge for so long. I have read some of his recent posts over there saying he "distrusts" me . This was due to forum drama BS from 2 years ago where he was upset i shut down the "Skeptics forum", a troll infested shithole at the first LCF, under the direction of Dylan. JFK blew a gasket and thought we were going to "burn books" next and commited "Admin suicide" by deleting his own account. Ever since, he seems to hold a grudge, due to what? Putting trolls in their place? Tell the man to get a grip. We welcome JFK and he is free to sign up here, we promise we wont bite, and we also promise we wont burn books. Heck, we even have our own library courtesy of Sanders. Sanders was trying to set up the library at the first LCF before the meltdown and after JFK thought we were going to "burn books". We also provide a clean atmosphere free of trolls although have plenty still here who "disagree" with us, they just dont come around much.... |
|
|
|
May 28 2008, 08:10 PM
Post
#2
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
Hello and welcome MM,
I'm not a pilot, but I am a scientist/engineer, not exactly unfamiliar with flight physics, data analysis, and a few other subjects. I did some of the early work on the USAF 84 RADES data last year for all 4 flights, but I was more interested in altitudes and velocities, so I used the .XLS spreadsheet data prepared by USAF 84 RADES for "verification." Another researcher here has more experience with the R3 software than I do, but that person is a writer in Europe and hasn't been around a whole lot. I'll likely be away from the computer for quite a while soon myself and likely won't be around to answer a lot of questions, and I mainly work in spreadsheets as a rule. Since there were no SSFDR's recovered for AA11/WTC1N and UA175/WTC2So, I was interested in obtaining the velocities, lat/lon, and altitude from the RADES data. I needed to use a (now-more accurate) mathematical approximation to find the velocity. My preliminary/stagnant results are linked at: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10499497 There is a LOT of technical information on those charts- I've heard that many pilots have a challenge reading them. I predict that "JFK" will find no shortage of strange things in the USAF RADES data. I didn't look at the transponder times lately, but I believe that I marked them on my charts. I wouldn't expect a logical pattern on Mode 3 for most of the flights, either. "JFK" will want to review primary vs. secondary radar as well: http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=8803 Hope this helps, d Admins: this should probably be moved to the AA11 section- the question looked to be about AA11 only from what I could tell. EDIT: I would advise "JFK" not to try to compare the AA11 RADES data against the UA175 data. It will be difficult enough to make sense out of one data set against itself- and AA11 is the "best behaved" flight from what I found. This post has been edited by dMole: May 28 2008, 08:18 PM |
|
|
|
May 28 2008, 08:47 PM
Post
#3
|
|
![]() Group: Respected Member Posts: 1,107 Joined: 2-May 08 From: Canada Member No.: 3,264 |
Hello and welcome MM, I'm not a pilot, but I am a scientist/engineer, not exactly unfamiliar with flight physics, data analysis, and a few other subjects. I did some of the early work on the USAF 84 RADES data last year for all 4 flights, but I was more interested in altitudes and velocities, so I used the .XLS spreadsheet data prepared by USAF 84 RADES for "verification." Another researcher here has more experience with the R3 software than I do, but that person is a writer in Europe and hasn't been around a whole lot. I'll likely be away from the computer for quite a while soon myself and likely won't be around to answer a lot of questions, and I mainly work in spreadsheets as a rule. Since there were no SSFDR's recovered for AA11/WTC1N and UA175/WTC2So, I was interested in obtaining the velocities, lat/lon, and altitude from the RADES data. I needed to use a (now-more accurate) mathematical approximation to find the velocity. My preliminary/stagnant results are linked at: http://pf911t.org/forum//index....&p=10499497 There is a LOT of technical information on those charts- I've heard that many pilots have a challenge reading them. I predict that "JFK" will find no shortage of strange things in the USAF RADES data. I didn't look at the transponder times lately, but I believe that I marked them on my charts. I wouldn't expect a logical pattern on Mode 3 for most of the flights, either. "JFK" will want to review primary vs. secondary radar as well: http://pf911t.org/forum//index.php?showtopic=8803 Hope this helps, d Admins: this should probably be moved to the AA11 section- the question looked to be about AA11 only from what I could tell. EDIT: I would advise "JFK" not to try to compare the AA11 RADES data against the UA175 data. It will be difficult enough to make sense out of one data set against itself- and AA11 is the "best behaved" flight from what I found. On the Charts..there are some very tiny Red (Beacon) Dots...what does Beacon mean? |
|
|
|
May 29 2008, 08:06 AM
Post
#3
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 7 Joined: 14-December 06 Member No.: 320 |
Long time no see MM.. .good to see ya.. Not really sure what JFK is trying to get at, but nothing looks "out of the ordinary" in his screenshots. AA11 was assigned a squawk and the transponder was turned off. UA175 was also assigned a squawk, and from what i understand, UA175 transponder code was changed, the transponder was never turned off. Keep in mind, all the above is according to the govt story. Tell JFK i said you're welcome.. and also tell him to stop holding a grudge for so long. I have read some of his recent posts over there saying he "distrusts" me . This was due to forum drama BS from 2 years ago where he was upset i shut down the "Skeptics forum", a troll infested shithole at the first LCF, under the direction of Dylan. JFK blew a gasket and thought we were going to "burn books" next and commited "Admin suicide" by deleting his own account. Ever since, he seems to hold a grudge, due to what? Putting trolls in their place? Tell the man to get a grip. We welcome JFK and he is free to sign up here, we promise we wont bite, and we also promise we wont burn books. Heck, we even have our own library courtesy of Sanders. Sanders was trying to set up the library at the first LCF before the meltdown and after JFK thought we were going to "burn books". We also provide a clean atmosphere free of trolls although have plenty still here who "disagree" with us, they just dont come around much.... Thanks for the reply Rob. I'm sorry that I've been such a stranger here but maintaining a life and being active in the best 9/11 forums isn't easily accomplished. Also I lack the technical expertise to offer much in the line of constructive posts here. Hopefully JFK will "bury the hatchet" (assuming he hasn't already). It was a sad day when so many of the best LCF veterans felt compelled to leave. MM |
|
|
|
May 29 2008, 08:41 AM
Post
#4
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Thanks for the reply Rob. I'm sorry that I've been such a stranger here but maintaining a life and being active in the best 9/11 forums isn't easily accomplished. I know the feeling at times. QUOTE Also I lack the technical expertise to offer much in the line of constructive posts here. I beg to differ. I read alot of your posts here and elsewhere. You seem to have a good grasp of the information. QUOTE Hopefully JFK will "bury the hatchet" Hopefully. The least thing we need right now is to give fodder to our enemies. |
|
|
|
May 29 2008, 08:32 AM
Post
#4
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
On the Charts..there are some very tiny Red (Beacon) Dots...what does Beacon mean? According to the "official" NTSB report for TWA800 (yet another industrial-size can of worms), [pg. 2] "A 'primary' only target is received as a reflection of radar energy only. A 'secondary' or 'beacon' only target is recorded as a response of the aircraft's transponder to interrogation by the [primary] radar system. A 'reinforced' target is recorded by the radar system in lieu of a primary or secondary target when transponder information is coincident with and reinforces a reflection of radar energy. Generally, secondary and reinforced targets are referred to as "secondary" targets." http://www.ntsb.gov/Events/twa800/exhibits...4_misradvis.pdf NOTE: I had to type the above- it wouldn't cut & paste, so I may have missed something in all the screen-switching, but I tried to preserve the integrity of the quote (and the source is provided). In other words Leslie, the USAF radar yells "Who are you, and how high are you?" [The USAF and FAA radars already know the distance and direction to the "target" BTW ]. If someone/something yells back "I'm AA11, and I'm at 29,000 feet aMSL," then that is a secondary or "beacon" return, or a red dot in this case. I believe that primary radar returns would be a green dot in the LCF pictures. |
|
|
|
May 28 2008, 10:24 PM
Post
#4
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Long time no see MM.. .good to see ya..
Not really sure what JFK is trying to get at, but nothing looks "out of the ordinary" in his screenshots. AA11 was assigned a squawk and the transponder was turned off. UA175 was also assigned a squawk, and from what i understand, UA175 transponder code was changed, the transponder was never turned off. Keep in mind, all the above is according to the govt story. Tell JFK i said you're welcome.. and also tell him to stop holding a grudge for so long. I have read some of his recent posts over there saying he "distrusts" me . This was due to forum drama BS from 2 years ago where he was upset i shut down the "Skeptics forum", a troll infested shithole at the first LCF, under the direction of Dylan. JFK blew a gasket and thought we were going to "burn books" next and commited "Admin suicide" by deleting his own account. Ever since, he seems to hold a grudge, due to what? Putting trolls in their place? Tell the man to get a grip. We welcome JFK and he is free to sign up here, we promise we wont bite, and we also promise we wont burn books. Heck, we even have our own library courtesy of Sanders. Sanders was trying to set up the library at the first LCF before the meltdown and after JFK thought we were going to "burn books". We also provide a clean atmosphere free of trolls although have plenty still here who "disagree" with us, they just dont come around much.... |
|
|
|
May 29 2008, 08:06 AM
Post
#5
|
|
|
Group: Student Forum Pilot Posts: 7 Joined: 14-December 06 Member No.: 320 |
Long time no see MM.. .good to see ya.. Not really sure what JFK is trying to get at, but nothing looks "out of the ordinary" in his screenshots. AA11 was assigned a squawk and the transponder was turned off. UA175 was also assigned a squawk, and from what i understand, UA175 transponder code was changed, the transponder was never turned off. Keep in mind, all the above is according to the govt story. Tell JFK i said you're welcome.. and also tell him to stop holding a grudge for so long. I have read some of his recent posts over there saying he "distrusts" me . This was due to forum drama BS from 2 years ago where he was upset i shut down the "Skeptics forum", a troll infested shithole at the first LCF, under the direction of Dylan. JFK blew a gasket and thought we were going to "burn books" next and commited "Admin suicide" by deleting his own account. Ever since, he seems to hold a grudge, due to what? Putting trolls in their place? Tell the man to get a grip. We welcome JFK and he is free to sign up here, we promise we wont bite, and we also promise we wont burn books. Heck, we even have our own library courtesy of Sanders. Sanders was trying to set up the library at the first LCF before the meltdown and after JFK thought we were going to "burn books". We also provide a clean atmosphere free of trolls although have plenty still here who "disagree" with us, they just dont come around much.... Thanks for the reply Rob. I'm sorry that I've been such a stranger here but maintaining a life and being active in the best 9/11 forums isn't easily accomplished. Also I lack the technical expertise to offer much in the line of constructive posts here. Hopefully JFK will "bury the hatchet" (assuming he hasn't already). It was a sad day when so many of the best LCF veterans felt compelled to leave. MM |
|
|
|
May 29 2008, 08:32 AM
Post
#6
|
|
![]() Group: Global Mod Posts: 5,019 Joined: 2-October 07 From: USA, a Federal corporation Member No.: 2,294 |
On the Charts..there are some very tiny Red (Beacon) Dots...what does Beacon mean? According to the "official" NTSB report for TWA800 (yet another industrial-size can of worms), [pg. 2] "A 'primary' only target is received as a reflection of radar energy only. A 'secondary' or 'beacon' only target is recorded as a response of the aircraft's transponder to interrogation by the [primary] radar system. A 'reinforced' target is recorded by the radar system in lieu of a primary or secondary target when transponder information is coincident with and reinforces a reflection of radar energy. Generally, secondary and reinforced targets are referred to as "secondary" targets." http://www.ntsb.gov/Events/twa800/exhibits...4_misradvis.pdf NOTE: I had to type the above- it wouldn't cut & paste, so I may have missed something in all the screen-switching, but I tried to preserve the integrity of the quote (and the source is provided). In other words Leslie, the USAF radar yells "Who are you, and how high are you?" [The USAF and FAA radars already know the distance and direction to the "target" BTW ]. If someone/something yells back "I'm AA11, and I'm at 29,000 feet aMSL," then that is a secondary or "beacon" return, or a red dot in this case. I believe that primary radar returns would be a green dot in the LCF pictures. |
|
|
|
May 29 2008, 08:41 AM
Post
#7
|
|
![]() ![]() Group: Admin Posts: 9,745 Joined: 13-August 06 Member No.: 1 |
Thanks for the reply Rob. I'm sorry that I've been such a stranger here but maintaining a life and being active in the best 9/11 forums isn't easily accomplished. I know the feeling at times. QUOTE Also I lack the technical expertise to offer much in the line of constructive posts here. I beg to differ. I read alot of your posts here and elsewhere. You seem to have a good grasp of the information. QUOTE Hopefully JFK will "bury the hatchet" Hopefully. The least thing we need right now is to give fodder to our enemies. |
|
|
|
![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 15th November 2020 - 03:12 AM |
Strange Transponder Data, Difference Between Flight 11 and 175 |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 13th November 2020 - 09:57 AM |
![]() ![]() |
![]() ![]() |
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 15th November 2020 - 03:11 AM |
Miragememories Strange Transponder Data May 28 2008, 01:25 PM
dMole Hello and welcome MM,
I'm not a pilot, but I ... May 28 2008, 08:10 PM
Leslie Landry QUOTE (dMole @ May 28 2008, 08:10 PM) Hel... May 28 2008, 08:47 PM
dMole QUOTE (Leslie Landry @ May 28 2008, 05:47... May 29 2008, 08:32 AM
rob balsamo Long time no see MM.. .good to see ya..
Not reall... May 28 2008, 10:24 PM
Miragememories QUOTE (rob balsamo @ May 27 2008, 12:24 A... May 29 2008, 08:06 AM
rob balsamo QUOTE (Miragememories @ May 29 2008, 08:0... May 29 2008, 08:41 AMSource file links: